[exim] Multiple spamd servers.

2005-11-09 Thread Ian FREISLICH
Hi I wonder if others share my frustration. I want to continue to scan subtitted mail and make decisions based on the score. The only trouble is that most of the users that use us to smart host are on space that is RBLed into the darkest of RBL space and the RBL scores are sufficient to make the

Re: [exim] Multiple spamd servers.

2005-11-09 Thread Tony Finch
On Wed, 9 Nov 2005, Ian FREISLICH wrote: > > I wonder if others share my frustration. I want to continue to > scan subtitted mail and make decisions based on the score. The > only trouble is that most of the users that use us to smart host > are on space that is RBLed into the darkest of RBL spac

Re: [exim] Multiple spamd servers.

2005-11-09 Thread exim-users
Ian FREISLICH schrieb: Hi I wonder if others share my frustration. I want to continue to scan subtitted mail and make decisions based on the score. The only trouble is that most of the users that use us to smart host are on space that is RBLed into the darkest of RBL space and the RBL scores

Re: [exim] Multiple spamd servers.

2005-11-09 Thread Michael Haardt
On Wed, Nov 09, 2005 at 10:28:22AM +0200, Ian FREISLICH wrote: > The only other way that I can think of is to allow exim to have > sets of spamd_address options so that I could scan submitted mail > with a spamd using a particular configuration and incoming SMTP on > a different spamd. This will m

Re: [exim] Multiple spamd servers.

2005-11-09 Thread Tom Kistner
Michael Haardt wrote: denymessage = Spam detected !authenticated = * spam= incoming-$primary_hostname/servers=spamd1 783 : \ spamd2 783 : ... run multiple *different* spamd servers since some years now. But the result o

Re: [exim] Multiple spamd servers.

2005-11-09 Thread Tony Finch
On Wed, 9 Nov 2005, Tom Kistner wrote: > > I'm with Tony here: You already can send a username to spamd. Changes in rule > treatment should be implemented in spamd, using the submitted username as the > key. I wasn't thinking of anything user-dependent - and Ian said that he doesn't want to do tha

Re: [exim] Multiple spamd servers.

2005-11-09 Thread Ian FREISLICH
Tony Finch wrote: > On Wed, 9 Nov 2005, Ian FREISLICH wrote: > > > > I wonder if others share my frustration. I want to continue to > > scan subtitted mail and make decisions based on the score. The > > only trouble is that most of the users that use us to smart host > > are on space that is RBLe

Re: [exim] Multiple spamd servers.

2005-11-09 Thread Michael Haardt
On Wed, Nov 09, 2005 at 10:44:18AM +0100, Tom Kistner wrote: > Michael Haardt wrote: > > >>denymessage = Spam detected > >>!authenticated = * > >>spam= incoming-$primary_hostname/servers=spamd1 783 : \ > >>spamd2 783 : ... > > >run multiple

Re: [exim] Multiple spamd servers.

2005-11-09 Thread Tony Finch
On Wed, 9 Nov 2005, Ian FREISLICH wrote: > > I'm not sure how I would get that data from exim into the remote spamd. SpamAssassin can parse this kind of thing out of Received: lines. > Also, my C foo is orders of magnitude stronger than my Perl foo. > So if I'm to do the work, I stand a much bett

Re: [exim] Multiple spamd servers.

2005-11-09 Thread Marc Perkel
Ian FREISLICH wrote: Hi I wonder if others share my frustration. I want to continue to scan subtitted mail and make decisions based on the score. The only trouble is that most of the users that use us to smart host are on space that is RBLed into the darkest of RBL space and the RBL scores

Re: [exim] Multiple spamd servers.

2005-11-09 Thread Ian FREISLICH
Marc Perkel wrote: > Ian FREISLICH wrote: > >I wonder if others share my frustration. I want to continue to > >scan subtitted mail and make decisions based on the score. The > >only trouble is that most of the users that use us to smart host > >are on space that is RBLed into the darkest of RBL s