Re: [Finale] Pedal markings

2003-07-13 Thread Daniel Dorff
One sees a wide variety of pedal notations and degrees of how much to indicate or just imply, but I'd like to recommend not using lines any more than necessary. The pianist's eye must flow through a lot of symbols and keep thinking about feeling the music, not the notation, so seeing 5 parallel li

Re: [Finale] Pedal markings

2003-07-12 Thread John Howell
Michael Edwards wrote, as part of a well-presented opinion: I use pedalling to a degree of precision that I feel will exclude those styles of pedalling that I don't consider suit the type of music I'm writing. I would probably count proper pedalling on piano as being in a category along with

Re: [Finale] Pedal markings

2003-07-11 Thread Michael Edwards
[Richard Huggins:] >Just for the record, as a pianist I can't agree with Michael Edwards' rather >global criticism of the pedalling decisions and techniques of the pianists >he has heard. Well, I see nothing wrong with saying what I like or don't, and whether I want it done in my own music o

Re: [Finale] Pedal markings

2003-07-11 Thread Richard Huggins
Just for the record, as a pianist I can't agree with Michael Edwards' rather global criticism of the pedalling decisions and techniques of the pianists he has heard. (To his credit he admits that "opinions vary widely." And of course, not just about pedalling!) Nor do I agree that comprehensive ped

Re: [Finale] Pedal markings

2003-07-11 Thread Michael Edwards
[Ken Fowler:] >The User Manual talks about three ways to indicate pedaling. Is >there a generally accepted style in use today to indicate pedaling? I normally use a horizontal line beneath the lower staff to indicate the duration during which the pedal is down. To indicate a change, I break

Re: [Finale] Pedal markings

2003-07-10 Thread Patsy Moore
In message <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, D. Keneth Fowler <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes > >“A great piece is always better >than any performance of it” - > >André Previn at an award ceremony in his honor I expect it was you that quoted this a week or so ago. I passed it on ye

RE: [Finale] Pedal markings

2003-07-10 Thread Fisher, Allen
EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Thursday, July 10, 2003 4:04 PM To: [EMAIL PROTECTED]; [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: Re: [Finale] Pedal markings In a message dated 7/10/03 10:44:43 AM, [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: << That said, however, I think that pedal markings should be used only when absolutel

Re: [Finale] Pedal markings

2003-07-10 Thread NRaspa
In a message dated 7/10/03 10:44:43 AM, [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: << That said, however, I think that pedal markings should be used only when absolutely necessary, places where a pianist would not normally expect to use the pedal. >> I am using pedal markings extensively in works that I am wri

Re: [Finale] Pedal markings

2003-07-10 Thread Harold Owen
Keneth Fowler writes: Until now I have not been asked to engrave any piano music. But the time has come. The User Manual talks about three ways to indicate pedaling. Is there a generally accepted style in use today to indicate pedaling? Is it one of the plans in the Manual? If not, what is con

[Finale] Pedal markings

2003-07-10 Thread D. Keneth Fowler
Until now I have not been asked to engrave any piano music. But the time has come. The User Manual talks about three ways to indicate pedaling. Is there a generally accepted style in use today to indicate pedaling? Is it one of the plans in the Manual? If not, what is considered good practice t