Re: [Finale] rests in 18/8

2003-11-04 Thread Christopher BJ Smith
Hm, again. I regularly accept differences between rest notation and the same rhythm in notes; for example I syncopate note values, but I would never notate a rest syncopated, example: 1/8, 1/4, 1/8 is perfect as notes, but make the 1/4 a rest and it is not acceptable to me. I would have to bre

Re: [Finale] rests in 18/8

2003-11-04 Thread Johannes Gebauer
I am sure this is a good idea, however, in an "Urtext" edition of 18th century French music I somehow feel this kind of symbol is a little out of place. I haven't quite decided what to do, but I tend towards using exactly what the source gives, which is a normal half rest for half a measure. The a

Re: [Finale] rests in 18/8

2003-11-04 Thread Andrew Stiller
At 9:45 PM +0100 11/03/03, Johannes Gebauer wrote: How would one indicate a rest for exactly half a measure of 18/8 (which is basically two 9/8 measures, with six beats per measure, one beat per dotted quarter)? In the 18th century print I am working from I see a half rest, how would this be notate

Re: [Finale] rests in 18/8

2003-11-04 Thread Klaas de Jong
Hm, I would ask myself: 'What would be a clear notation of a *note* of the same length?' and I guess three tied dotted quarter notes could be one rigth answer, so for the rest I would choose three dotted quarter rests. This notation really shows the 'triple-ness' of the time. Klaas. Op 3-nov-0

RE: [Finale] rests in 18/8

2003-11-03 Thread Fisher, Allen
Hmm...Even though I do not like dotted rests, I'd probably do it as a dotted half rest and a dotted quarter rest or as three dotted quarter rests... Allen -Original Message- From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of Gebauer, Johannes Sent: Monday, November 03, 2003 2:

Re: [Finale] rests in 18/8

2003-11-03 Thread Christopher BJ Smith
At 9:45 PM +0100 11/03/03, Johannes Gebauer wrote: How would one indicate a rest for exactly half a measure of 18/8 (which is basically two 9/8 measures, with six beats per measure, one beat per dotted quarter)? In the 18th century print I am working from I see a half rest, how would this be notate