Re: [Finale] alto as tenor? now Brandenburg 2

2007-09-11 Thread [EMAIL PROTECTED]
> Not knowing anything about the trumpet, the horn and Brandenburg 2, here > is one more thing perhaps worth considering: > > There is an instrument now referred to as the baroque clarinet. It is > not the chalumaux, and sounds quite different. It plays in a pretty high > register. This is the

Re: [Finale] alto as tenor? now Brandenburg 2

2007-09-11 Thread Johannes Gebauer
Not knowing anything about the trumpet, the horn and Brandenburg 2, here is one more thing perhaps worth considering: There is an instrument now referred to as the baroque clarinet. It is not the chalumaux, and sounds quite different. It plays in a pretty high register. This is the reason it i

Re: [Finale] alto as tenor? now Brandenburg 2

2007-09-10 Thread Aaron Rabushka
Are you thining of Thurston Dart? Aaron J. Rabushka [EMAIL PROTECTED] http://users.waymark.net/arabushk - Original Message - From: "Raymond Horton" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> To: Sent: Monday, September 10, 2007 3:09 PM Subject: Re: [Finale] alto as tenor? now Brandenburg 2

Re: [Finale] alto as tenor? now Brandenburg 2

2007-09-10 Thread Aaron Rabushka
ect: Re: [Finale] alto as tenor? now Brandenburg 2 > On 9/10/07, Raymond Horton <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > I wasn't just being funny with my "can of worms" answer. The theory of > > horn in place of trumpet on Brandenburg 2 (BWV 1047) was presented back >

Re: [Finale] alto as tenor? now Brandenburg 2

2007-09-10 Thread Kim Patrick Clow
On 9/10/07, Raymond Horton <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > I wasn't just being funny with my "can of worms" answer. The theory of > horn in place of trumpet on Brandenburg 2 (BWV 1047) was presented back > in the late 60s by one scholar who had latched upon a copy of a third > generation part labeled

Re: [Finale] alto as tenor? now Brandenburg 2

2007-09-10 Thread Raymond Horton
I wasn't just being funny with my "can of worms" answer. The theory of horn in place of trumpet on Brandenburg 2 (BWV 1047) was presented back in the late 60s by one scholar who had latched upon a copy of a third generation part labeled horn. There was an ensuing squabble, I believe, which tr