Re: Bach temperament, was: Re: [Finale] Is Finale 2006 trustable for Mac yet?

2005-09-03 Thread David W. Fenton
On 2 Sep 2005 at 0:19, John Howell wrote: At 6:34 PM +0200 9/1/05, Johannes Gebauer wrote: On 18:07 Uhr Brad Beyenhof wrote: Life would be so much easier if only (3/2)12=(2/1)7. Have you heard about the recently discovered Bach tuning, which is hidden on the title page of the

Re: Bach temperament, was: Re: [Finale] Is Finale 2006 trustable for Mac yet?

2005-09-02 Thread John Howell
At 6:34 PM +0200 9/1/05, Johannes Gebauer wrote: On 18:07 Uhr Brad Beyenhof wrote: Life would be so much easier if only (3/2)12=(2/1)7. Have you heard about the recently discovered Bach tuning, which is hidden on the title page of the well-tempered manuscript? This has been much

Bach temperament, was: Re: [Finale] Is Finale 2006 trustable for Mac yet?

2005-09-01 Thread Johannes Gebauer
On 18:07 Uhr Brad Beyenhof wrote: Life would be so much easier if only (3/2)12=(2/1)7. Have you heard about the recently discovered Bach tuning, which is hidden on the title page of the well-tempered manuscript? No... do you have a reference (preferably online) where I can read about

Re: Bach temperament, was: Re: [Finale] Is Finale 2006 trustable for Mac yet?

2005-09-01 Thread Brad Beyenhof
On 9/1/05, Johannes Gebauer [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: On 18:07 Uhr Brad Beyenhof wrote: Life would be so much easier if only (3/2)^12=(2/1)^7. Have you heard about the recently discovered Bach tuning, which is hidden on the title page of the well-tempered manuscript? No... do you have a

Re: Bach temperament, was: Re: [Finale] Is Finale 2006 trustable for Mac yet?

2005-09-01 Thread David W. Fenton
On 1 Sep 2005 at 18:34, Johannes Gebauer wrote: On 18:07 Uhr Brad Beyenhof wrote: Life would be so much easier if only (3/2)12=(2/1)7. Have you heard about the recently discovered Bach tuning, which is hidden on the title page of the well-tempered manuscript? No... do you have a

Re: Bach temperament, was: Re: [Finale] Is Finale 2006 trustable for Mac yet?

2005-09-01 Thread Johannes Gebauer
On 23:03 Uhr David W. Fenton wrote: It's clearly not real scholarship, because real scholars don't make claims like: [snip] David, I don't doubt you are right, yet that doesn't actually say anything about the findings, it just says something about the scholar. His methods may be

Re: Bach temperament, was: Re: [Finale] Is Finale 2006 trustable for Mac yet?

2005-09-01 Thread David W. Fenton
On 1 Sep 2005 at 23:43, Johannes Gebauer wrote: On 23:03 Uhr David W. Fenton wrote: It's clearly not real scholarship, because real scholars don't make claims like: [snip] David, I don't doubt you are right, yet that doesn't actually say anything about the findings, it just says