Re: [Flac] FLAC: general question

2007-07-25 Thread Rippit the Ogg Frog
Perhaps a more important question is how much electricity is required to decode FLAC, and how much heat is generated - for embedded CPUs of course. FLAC might not become popular for portable players if it shortens their battery life significantly. While there is the problem that .flacs take u

Re: [Flac] FLAC: general question

2007-07-25 Thread Brian Willoughby
Harry, Another thing to consider is the balance between CPU efficiency and disk speed. On some of my systems, decoding a FLAC file to AIFF (or WAV) uses 100% of the CPU. That's because the drive is faster than the CPU, so the CPU is constantly working. Moving to a 4-processor system, I

Re: [Flac] FLAC: general question

2007-07-25 Thread Brian Willoughby
Harry, Keep in mind that the processor load will be different for every processor model. PowerPC G4, G5, and then all the implementations of x86. Processor load does not depend upon clock speed - all that clock speed determines is how fast the operation can be done, and particularly whe

Re: [Flac] FLAC: general question

2007-07-25 Thread Harry Sack
2007/7/24, Ivo Emanuel Gonçalves <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>: On 7/24/07, Greg M. <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > Ivo, Harry is asking about CPU usage of the DEcoder, > not the ENcoder. Sorry, my bad. I believe that FLAC's decoding is somewhat faster than most other lossless formats, as FLAC is a much le

Re: [Flac] FLAC: general question

2007-07-24 Thread Ivo Emanuel Gonçalves
On 7/24/07, Greg M. <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: Ivo, Harry is asking about CPU usage of the DEcoder, not the ENcoder. Sorry, my bad. I believe that FLAC's decoding is somewhat faster than most other lossless formats, as FLAC is a much less complex format. ___

Re: [Flac] FLAC: general question

2007-07-24 Thread Greg M.
Ivo, Harry is asking about CPU usage of the DEcoder, not the ENcoder. And I believe FLAC is designed to use as little CPU as possible for decoding, thereby encouraging hardware manufacturers to include FLAC support. Encoding, however, is another matter, always done on a computer, and requiring a

Re: [Flac] FLAC: general question

2007-07-24 Thread Ivo Emanuel Gonçalves
The amount of CPU the FLAC encoder uses is dependant on how much compression you will use. The less compression you need, the less CPU power that will be used. Of course, the whole point of FLAC is to get as much compression as possible without losing any audio fidelity. I don't know of any sit

[Flac] FLAC: general question

2007-07-24 Thread Harry Sack
hi FLAC list! I have a general question about the FLAC decoder. Is it true the FLAC decoder requires less CPU power then a MP3 decoder? And if yes, is there somebody who can give me a comparison e.g. FLAC decoder uses 50% less CPU power then a MP3 decoder or is this difference only minimal? thx