Re: [flac-dev] About SSE intrinsincs in decoder

2022-07-08 Thread Martijn van Beurden
Op do 7 jul. 2022 om 09:46 schreef olivier tristan : > Perhaps it is possible to add a switch to the encoder to create FLAC files > that are optimized for decoding speed instead of size. Would that be > something you would use? For example trading in 5% less compression against > 30% more decoding

Re: [flac-dev] About SSE intrinsincs in decoder

2022-07-07 Thread olivier tristan
Le 07/07/2022 à 09:34, Martijn van Beurden a écrit : Op do 7 jul. 2022 om 09:07 schreef olivier tristan : > Hence even small optimization are very welcomed :) I presume you use libFLAC directly then. Sadly there is little left to optimize in the decoder. Below is an excerpt of the output of gp

Re: [flac-dev] About SSE intrinsincs in decoder

2022-07-07 Thread Martijn van Beurden
Op do 7 jul. 2022 om 09:07 schreef olivier tristan : > Hence even small optimization are very welcomed :) I presume you use libFLAC directly then. Sadly there is little left to optimize in the decoder. Below is an excerpt of the output of gprof on flac decoding a track > % cumulative self

Re: [flac-dev] About SSE intrinsincs in decoder

2022-07-07 Thread olivier tristan
I work on virtual music instrument ( uvi.net ) and we store all the samples in FLAC format because of its compression level, its lossless capability and its decoding speed. This is clearly the best in the world and we love it. We have a streaming engine tailored to its use. In the case of a

Re: [flac-dev] About SSE intrinsincs in decoder

2022-07-06 Thread Martijn van Beurden
Op wo 6 jul. 2022 om 20:36 schreef Martijn van Beurden : > > I am aware that the following changes affect decoding speed > - https://github.com/xiph/flac/commit/1bec35e33757fc38261b0acfa3c032e720d2baf0 > - https://github.com/xiph/flac/commit/63ac1c37bebbda5ca61ad5a05a1d8fba2883f629 > Sorry, small

Re: [flac-dev] About SSE intrinsincs in decoder

2022-07-06 Thread Martijn van Beurden
Olivier, On a more general note, do you experience the decoding speed of libFLAC as a bottleneck in your application? Decoding speed of FLAC is already best-in-class among lossless audio codecs, so I actually wasn't expecting anyone to object to a (small) decrease in decoding speed. There have bee

Re: [flac-dev] About SSE intrinsincs in decoder

2022-07-05 Thread Martijn van Beurden
Op di 5 jul. 2022 om 09:41 schreef olivier tristan : > You do not talk about the SSE 4.1 version in your bench. > > Have you tried this use case ? > I compared 4 compiles: one without any changes (so with all variants of the lpc functions, including the SSE4.1 ones) and three with variants of pla

Re: [flac-dev] About SSE intrinsincs in decoder

2022-07-05 Thread olivier tristan
You do not talk about the SSE 4.1 version in your bench. Have you tried this use case ? Thanks ! Le 04/07/2022 à 19:23, Martijn van Beurden a écrit : Op ma 4 jul. 2022 om 15:06 schreef olivier tristan : While I can understand the rationale for manual assembly as 32 bits x86 is dea

Re: [flac-dev] About SSE intrinsincs in decoder

2022-07-04 Thread Martijn van Beurden
Op ma 4 jul. 2022 om 15:06 schreef olivier tristan : > While I can understand the rationale for manual assembly as 32 bits x86 > is dead, it seems a greater deal to remove all optimization including > intrinsic ones. > Yes, it does seem a great deal to remove all optimization, but it really isn't

[flac-dev] About SSE intrinsincs in decoder

2022-07-04 Thread olivier tristan
Hi All, Hi Martijn, I have just seen this commit https://github.com/xiph/flac/commit/febff86af03d2ccbdd4826c9555336916eb6ecb3 While I can understand the rationale for manual assembly as 32 bits x86 is dead, it seems a greater deal to remove all optimization including intrinsic ones. Maybe