[Framework-Team] Fwd: Re: [Plone] #9288: Improved commenting infrastructure

2010-12-08 Thread Timo Stollenwerk
Hi, Elizabeth came across a problem with p.a.discussion during her PLIP review: Authenticated users are currently not able to post a comment, they need the Member role to do so. Do we also want authenticated users to be able to post comments? Shall we just check for the Reply to Item permission?

Re: [Framework-Team] Fwd: Re: [Plone] #9288: Improved commenting infrastructure

2010-12-08 Thread Ross Patterson
Timo Stollenwerk li...@zmag.de writes: Hi, Elizabeth came across a problem with p.a.discussion during her PLIP review: Authenticated users are currently not able to post a comment, they need the Member role to do so. Do we also want authenticated users to be able to post comments? Shall

Re: [Framework-Team] Fwd: Re: [Plone] #9288: Improved commenting infrastructure

2010-12-08 Thread Raphael Ritz
Timo Stollenwerk wrote: Hi, Elizabeth came across a problem with p.a.discussion during her PLIP review: Authenticated users are currently not able to post a comment, they need the Member role to do so. Do we also want authenticated users to be able to post comments? Shall we just check for

Re: [Framework-Team] Fwd: plone.app.discussion UI review

2010-12-08 Thread Nathan Van Gheem
Hi Timo, PLIP REVIEW: Moderating comments by changing the workflow is gross. I think it's work the extra effort here to add a moderate comments checkbox to the add on configuration. QUESTION: In order to activate the moderation workflow for comments, the user has to go to the types