Re: Request to back out Luigis polled-net patch in -stable.

In message <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, Garance A Drosihn writes: >Poul-Henning included one comment about "track records" which may >have been a bit harsh, but if you ignore that one sentence than >everything he said seemed pretty reasoned (ie, "calmly thought out", >as opposed to "emotional outburst"),

Re: Request to back out Luigis polled-net patch in -stable.

> > > I would also like to point to the parallel piece of code: Jun-Itohs > > > ALTQ for which he reliably has maintained a patch relative to the ... > > Yes; this is an excellent example of how it can be done better. > > Sorry guys, but aren't you comparing apples with oranges? As far as I No.

Re: Request to back out Luigis polled-net patch in -stable.

At 9:44 PM +0100 12/7/01, Marko Zec wrote: Mike Smith wrote: > > I would also like to point to the parallel piece of code: Jun-Itohs > ALTQ for which he reliably has maintained a patch relative to the > 4.X branch and which despite various peoples requests have not > > haphazardly been comm

Re: Request to back out Luigis polled-net patch in -stable.

Mike Smith wrote: > > Subject: Request to back out Luigis polled-net patch in -stable. > > I'm entirely in agreement with this; the decision to commit this code was > extremely ill-advised, and the best thing we can do now for everyone's > sake is to pull it as quickl

Re: Request to back out Luigis polled-net patch in -stable.

> To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Core isn't really the appropriate forum for asking for a back-out; arch and net are where this should have been discussed and reviewed in the first place. > Subject: Request to back out Luigis polled-net patch in -stable. I'm entirely in agreement with th

Request to back out Luigis polled-net patch in -stable.

--- Forwarded Message To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: Request to back out Luigis polled-net patch in -stable. From: Poul-Henning Kamp <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Date: Fri, 07 Dec 2001 17:13:24 +0100 Message-ID: <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Sender: [EMAIL PROTECTED] I have not read the ent

Re: Request to back out Luigis polled-net patch in -stable.

> > > I would also like to point to the parallel piece of code: Jun-Itohs > > > ALTQ for which he reliably has maintained a patch relative to the ... > > Yes; this is an excellent example of how it can be done better. > > Sorry guys, but aren't you comparing apples with oranges? As far as I No.

Re: Request to back out Luigis polled-net patch in -stable.

In message , Garance A Drosihn writes: >Poul-Henning included one comment about "track records" which may >have been a bit harsh, but if you ignore that one sentence than >everything he said seemed pretty reasoned (ie, "calmly thought out", >as opposed to "e

Re: Request to back out Luigis polled-net patch in -stable.

At 9:44 PM +0100 12/7/01, Marko Zec wrote: >Mike Smith wrote: > > > I would also like to point to the parallel piece of code: Jun-Itohs >> > ALTQ for which he reliably has maintained a patch relative to the >> > 4.X branch and which despite various peoples requests have not > > > haphazardly b

Re: Request to back out Luigis polled-net patch in -stable.

Mike Smith wrote: > > Subject: Request to back out Luigis polled-net patch in -stable. > > I'm entirely in agreement with this; the decision to commit this code was > extremely ill-advised, and the best thing we can do now for everyone's > sake is to pull it as quickl

Re: Request to back out Luigis polled-net patch in -stable.

> To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Core isn't really the appropriate forum for asking for a back-out; arch and net are where this should have been discussed and reviewed in the first place. > Subject: Request to back out Luigis polled-net patch in -stable. I'm entirely in agreemen

Request to back out Luigis polled-net patch in -stable.

--- Forwarded Message To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: Request to back out Luigis polled-net patch in -stable. From: Poul-Henning Kamp <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Date: Fri, 07 Dec 2001 17:13:24 +0100 Message-ID: <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Sender: [EMAIL PROTECTED] I have not read the ent