Re: tcpdump, rl, sis, fxp and multicast problems

2007-01-21 Thread Louis Mamakos
Matthew X. Economou wrote: not very important but wouldn't it be better to set the checksum to 0 instead of some arbitrary (?) and confusing value then ? No, as not setting the checksum is a (minor) optimization. Setting that field to any arbitrary constant means at least one completely

Re: tcpdump, rl, sis, fxp and multicast problems

2007-01-21 Thread Peter Jeremy
On Sun, 2007-Jan-21 09:32:10 -0500, Louis Mamakos wrote: However, since it is a 1's complement checksum, there is a distinguished value (all zero bits) that you could set the checksum field to that wouldn't occur for a normal computed checksum. That's a useful idea. Since the presence of a

RE: tcpdump, rl, sis, fxp and multicast problems

2007-01-20 Thread Matthew X. Economou
not very important but wouldn't it be better to set the checksum to 0 instead of some arbitrary (?) and confusing value then ? No, as not setting the checksum is a (minor) optimization. Setting that field to any arbitrary constant means at least one completely unnecessary CPU instruction per

Re: tcpdump, rl, sis, fxp and multicast problems

2007-01-19 Thread Roman Le Houelleur
that's very clever indeed ! Well, I was not quite sure it was actually performing the TCO (not to say I feel stupid ...). not very important but wouldn't it be better to set the checksum to 0 instead of some arbitrary (?) and confusing value then ? thank you anyway, Roman. Kris Kennaway wrote:

tcpdump, rl, sis, fxp and multicast problems

2007-01-18 Thread Roman Le Houelleur
Hi everyone, It's been about a year or so that I upgrade my box to RELENG_6 from time to time. I got some suprises this week, I've seen a few things that made me think of hardware problems but some are definitly soft. First and easy one, tcpdump -v does not show checksum error for UDP whereas

Re: tcpdump, rl, sis, fxp and multicast problems

2007-01-18 Thread Kris Kennaway
On Thu, Jan 18, 2007 at 03:34:46PM +0100, Roman Le Houelleur wrote: Hi everyone, It's been about a year or so that I upgrade my box to RELENG_6 from time to time. I got some suprises this week, I've seen a few things that made me think of hardware problems but some are definitly soft.