[Freedos-user] re: FDISK MBR and FORMAT questions

2005-07-25 Thread Eric Auer
Hi Gerry, > it says FDISK 1.2.1, and if I go to freedos.org and click > "software|base|fdisk" it says 1.2.1 as well, so why does mine say 1.3.0? The 1.3.0-beta version is popular as it is used on UltimateBootCD. It has debug features activated and it has a small fix in LBA BIOS detection, not m

[Freedos-user] re: FDISK MBR and FORMAT questions

2005-07-25 Thread Eric Auer
>any valid MBR starts with AA55, so if no AA55, FDISK /MBR might be done >automatically. Am I correct, Eric? Heck, no! Not at all! It ends with 55 aa, and even then, you know nothing about whether it contains a WORKING boot program. The MBR contains TWO things: The boot program and the partition

[Freedos-user] re: FDISK MBR and FORMAT questions

2005-07-25 Thread Eric Auer
Hi... > replace on disk error is dangerous, replace-on-missing AA55 is something > FDISK can ask the user in interactive mode, or batchfile can do FDISK /MBR. I wanted to make ABSOLUTELY CLEAR that nothing must ever automatically do FDISK /MBR with as only exception a CUSTOM install disk for un

[Freedos-user] re: FDISK MBR and FORMAT questions

2005-07-25 Thread Eric Auer
Hi again (wow, what a lot of traffic today, sigh...), > > I wanted to make ABSOLUTELY CLEAR that nothing must ever automatically > > do FDISK /MBR with as only exception a CUSTOM install disk for unattended > > install on known-empty / known-not-to-have-any-useful-MBR-program systems. > too bad,

Re: [Freedos-user] re: FDISK MBR and FORMAT questions

2005-07-25 Thread Bernd Blaauw
Eric Auer schreef: It ends with 55 aa, and even then, you know nothing about whether it contains a WORKING boot program. The MBR contains TWO things: The boot program and the partition data. FDISK had the VERY stupid function to delete BOTH and replace them with a fresh copy if the 55 aa was miss

Re: [Freedos-user] re: FDISK MBR and FORMAT questions

2005-07-25 Thread Bernd Blaauw
Eric Auer schreef: I wanted to make ABSOLUTELY CLEAR that nothing must ever automatically do FDISK /MBR with as only exception a CUSTOM install disk for unattended install on known-empty / known-not-to-have-any-useful-MBR-program systems. too bad, people want to have a working system being set

Re: [Freedos-user] re: FDISK MBR and FORMAT questions

2005-07-25 Thread Gerry Hickman
Hi All, Thanks for the excellent help with my questions. I'd just like to clarify things: I'm not saying that FDISK _should_ create anything automatically, I was just surprised that it didn't. The other thread implied that running FDISK without a valid MBR would cause creation of one, but Er

Re: [Freedos-user] re: FDISK MBR and FORMAT questions

2005-07-25 Thread Gerry Hickman
Hi Bernd, too bad, people want to have a working system being set up for them. if MS FDISK does alter MBR, then our FDISK should do so also. To be fair, FreeDOS gives options to write MBRs. The only reason I didn't choose this option in my experiments today was because I was testing for the

Re: [Freedos-user] re: FDISK MBR and FORMAT questions

2005-07-26 Thread Gerry Hickman
Hi, No idea whether MS FDISK zaps the MBR from time to time, but it better not. I learned a couple of things about FreeDOS FDISK today: 1. You can issue FDISK /CLEARALL and it clears everything! This is excellent, and much faster than MS-DOS with all it's silly warnings. It even clears the

Re: [Freedos-user] re: FDISK MBR and FORMAT questions

2005-08-01 Thread Aitor Santamaría Merino
Hi, Gerry Hickman escribió: What is the correct procedure for getting a "working boot program" into the "valid Master Boot Record", and who supplies this program? Is it Microsoft, Intel?? Hard drives usually have a default MBR, just as pre-formatted floppies have default FAT the information

Re: [Freedos-user] re: FDISK MBR and FORMAT questions

2005-08-02 Thread Jose Antonio Senna
Aitor Santamaria wrote: >One book I read (I think "Dissecting DOS") was considering the MBR as >part of the OS itself. I think "Dissecting DOS" it is not. It explains the MBR but says it is something independent form the O/S. JAS --- S