Hi,
http://gcc.gnu.org/bugs/management.html says that bugs in WAITING
state for more than three months, waiting for information on how
to reproduce the bug, can be closed, but it is unclear what the
"closed" state should be.
The description of WORKSFORME sounds closest: we don't know how to
repro
> The description of WORKSFORME sounds closest: we don't know how to
> reproduce the bug. Should that be used? The only other choices
> are FIXED (wrong), DUPLICATE (wrong), INVALID (we don't know that),
> or WONTFIX (we're not saying we won't fix it if we get a testcase).
>
> This came up beca
Peter Barada <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes:
> Saddest is that is that in a batch of various related bug closings, the
> blanket comment "M68k/ColdFire is not a primary platform - CLOSED".
That should not happen, they should only get their target milestone
bumped. I cannot remember having seen any c
> > Saddest is that is that in a batch of various related bug closings, the
> > blanket comment "M68k/ColdFire is not a primary platform - CLOSED".
>
> That should not happen, they should only get their target milestone
> bumped. I cannot remember having seen any case of a bug being _closed_
> jus
On Fri, Jan 12, 2007 at 12:41:08PM +0100, Eric Botcazou wrote:
> > > Saddest is that is that in a batch of various related bug closings, the
> > > blanket comment "M68k/ColdFire is not a primary platform - CLOSED".
> >
> > That should not happen, they should only get their target milestone
> > bump
On Jan 11, 2007, at 10:47 PM, Joe Buck wrote:
The description of WORKSFORME sounds closest: we don't know how to
reproduce the bug. Should that be used?
No, not generally. This should only be used if someone says, I
compile foo on platform bar and it didn't build and then someone
tries bu
Mike Stump wrote:
> On Jan 11, 2007, at 10:47 PM, Joe Buck wrote:
>> The description of WORKSFORME sounds closest: we don't know how to
>> reproduce the bug. Should that be used?
>
> No, not generally.
Of the states we have, WORKSFORME seems best to me, and I agree with Joe
that there's benefit
