Re: [DISCUSS] Move common, hdfs, mapreduce contrib components to apache-extras.org or elsewhere

2011-02-09 Thread Nigel Daley
After considering the feedback, I will move forward with calling a separate vote for each contrib (or small groups of contribs). The vote will ask the PMC to abandon the given contrib or move it to core. For those we agree to abandon, I will setup an Attic wiki that will point to the last SVN

[VOTE] Abandon failmon Common contrib

2011-02-09 Thread Nigel Daley
I think the PMC should abandon the failmon common contrib component. It's last meaningful contribution was it's original commit in August of 2008: HADOOP-3585. FailMon package for hardware failure monitoring and analysis of anomalies. (Ioannis Koltsidas via dhruba) Here is my +1. Nige

Re: [VOTE] Abandon failmon Common contrib

2011-02-09 Thread Tom White
+1 Tom On Wed, Feb 9, 2011 at 9:18 AM, Nigel Daley nda...@mac.com wrote: I think the PMC should abandon the failmon common contrib component.  It's last meaningful contribution was it's original commit in August of 2008: HADOOP-3585. FailMon package for hardware failure monitoring and

Re: [VOTE] Abandon failmon Common contrib

2011-02-09 Thread Allen Wittenauer
On Feb 9, 2011, at 9:18 AM, Nigel Daley wrote: I think the PMC should abandon the failmon common contrib component. It's last meaningful contribution was it's original commit in August of 2008: Are there any patches in the patch queue? When it comes to contrib, last commit

Re: [DISCUSS] Move common, hdfs, mapreduce contrib components to apache-extras.org or elsewhere

2011-02-09 Thread Nigel Daley
Hi Chris, You use the word 'project' over and over. These contrib modules are not Apache projects. They are source code directories within the various Hadoop subprojects. Reading thru attic.apache.org, I don't see how it directly relates. Surely not every 'svn remove dir' should be replaced