[RESULT] [IP CLEARANCE] [VOTE] Apache Celix shared memory Remote Service Admin implementation (2nd attempt)

2014-01-03 Thread Marcel Offermans
Formally closing this vote now. There were no -1 votes, so the vote is a success and the IP can now be imported by the project. On 18 Dec 2013, at 23:28 , Marcel Offermans marcel.offerm...@luminis.nl wrote: Note that this is a new vote, after cancelling the previous one. Apache Celix

Re: [IP CLEARANCE] [VOTE] Apache Celix shared memory Remote Service Admin implementation (2nd attempt)

2013-12-23 Thread Marcel Offermans
Hello Craig, As suggested, I updated the document to contain the location of the grant. Greetings, Marcel On 19 Dec 2013, at 17:29 pm, Craig L Russell craig.russ...@oracle.com wrote: Hi Marcel, The ip looks good, but the ip clearance document is our historical record and needs to be

Re: [IP CLEARANCE] [VOTE] Apache Celix shared memory Remote Service Admin implementation (2nd attempt)

2013-12-20 Thread Craig L Russell
Looks like the ip clearance has been updated. Good to go. Craig On Dec 19, 2013, at 8:29 AM, Craig L Russell wrote: Hi Marcel, The ip looks good, but the ip clearance document is our historical record and needs to be updated. No need to re-run the vote if the document is corrected. On

Re: [IP CLEARANCE] [VOTE] Apache Celix shared memory Remote Service Admin implementation (2nd attempt)

2013-12-19 Thread Craig L Russell
Hi Marcel, The ip looks good, but the ip clearance document is our historical record and needs to be updated. No need to re-run the vote if the document is corrected. On Dec 18, 2013, at 2:28 PM, Marcel Offermans wrote: Note that this is a new vote, after cancelling the previous one.

[IP CLEARANCE] [VOTE] Apache Celix shared memory remote service admin implementation

2013-12-18 Thread Marcel Offermans
Apache Celix received the donation of a shared memory implementation of the remote service admin specification. The donation is tracked by CELIX-29 [1]. The IP clearance document is placed under:

Re: [IP CLEARANCE] [VOTE] Apache Celix shared memory remote service admin implementation

2013-12-18 Thread Craig L Russell
Is there a software grant for this donation? I didn't see any reference from any of the below links (nor in CELIX-81 either). Craig On Dec 18, 2013, at 12:47 AM, Marcel Offermans wrote: Apache Celix received the donation of a shared memory implementation of the remote service admin

Re: [IP CLEARANCE] [VOTE] Apache Celix shared memory remote service admin implementation

2013-12-18 Thread Dave Brondsema
On 12/18/13 3:47 AM, Marcel Offermans wrote: Apache Celix received the donation of a shared memory implementation of the remote service admin specification. The donation is tracked by CELIX-29 [1]. The IP clearance document is placed under:

Re: [IP CLEARANCE] [VOTE] Apache Celix shared memory remote service admin implementation

2013-12-18 Thread Marcel Offermans
Hello Dave, Thanks for spotting that one. My mistake, I completely overlooked that field. I will correct it and, after also resolving the issue Craig brought up, start a new vote. Greetings, Marcel On 18 Dec 2013, at 17:24 , Dave Brondsema d...@brondsema.net wrote: On 12/18/13 3:47 AM,

Re: [IP CLEARANCE] [VOTE] Apache Celix shared memory remote service admin implementation

2013-12-18 Thread Marcel Offermans
Hello Craig, The reference to CELIX-29 is a mistake, CELIX-81 is the right issue. However, if I look at the SVN file containing a list of the grants, I do see the one related to this donation: Thales Nederland B.V. file: thales-nederland-celix-remote-services-admin-bundle.pdf for: A remote

[CANCELED] [IP CLEARANCE] [VOTE] Apache Celix shared memory remote service admin implementation

2013-12-18 Thread Marcel Offermans
Given the issues raised by Craig and Dave, I am cancelling this vote. I will fix the mistakes and start a new vote. Greetings, Marcel On 18 Dec 2013, at 9:47 , Marcel Offermans marcel.offerm...@luminis.nl wrote: Apache Celix received the donation of a shared memory implementation of the

[IP CLEARANCE] [VOTE] Apache Celix shared memory Remote Service Admin implementation (2nd attempt)

2013-12-18 Thread Marcel Offermans
Note that this is a new vote, after cancelling the previous one. Apache Celix received the donation of a shared memory implementation of the remote service admin specification. The donation is tracked by CELIX-81 [1]. The (updated) IP clearance document is placed under: