Noel,
It has been a while since I posted this and the conversation has gone
cold. I'd like to get some consensus on what the PPMC's role is so
that we can update the documentation.
See embedded comments below.
On 11/04/07, Martin Ritchie [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
On 11/04/07, Noel J. Bergman
Martin Ritchie wrote:
I'd like to get some consensus on what the PPMC's role is so
that we can update the documentation.
On 11/04/07, Noel J. Bergman [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
The PPMC has no standing within the ASF. It is a useful structure for the
Incubator, but the only binding votes
Upayavira wrote:
If your private@ list vote had three +1s from IPMC members (e.g.
your mentors), then IMO all you need to do is inform the IPMC of
the vote when complete.
Should probably notify the PMC at the time of the vote.
the request for an account should be sent by an IPMC member,
Noel J. Bergman wrote:
Upayavira wrote:
If your private@ list vote had three +1s from IPMC members (e.g.
your mentors), then IMO all you need to do is inform the IPMC of
the vote when complete.
Should probably notify the PMC at the time of the vote.
the request for an account
Carl Trieloff wrote:
A suggestion that one of our mentors had made to us was to do a poll for
concerns on the private list to see if PPMC was happy with the committer
to be added to the project (notice and to see if any of PPMC have
concerns). If all went well on the PPMC list, the
Noel J. Bergman wrote:
Carl Trieloff wrote:
A suggestion that one of our mentors had made to us was to do a poll for
concerns on the private list to see if PPMC was happy with the committer
to be added to the project (notice and to see if any of PPMC have
concerns). If all went well on
On 11/04/07, Noel J. Bergman [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
Cliff Schmidt wrote:
1. Only IPMC members (e.g. mentors) should send root requests for new
podling committers.
2. A podling committer vote requires three IPMC +1s to be approved
(ideally the mentors, assuming the project still has
On 4/6/07, Martin Ritchie [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
Ok, I think that has cleared things up a bit for me I'll send out
these requests that I've been sitting on for a few weeks now as we
need to get the accounts set up for our new committers.
Just as it appeared this subject was cleared up, Noel
Ok, I think that has cleared things up a bit for me I'll send out
these requests that I've been sitting on for a few weeks now as we
need to get the accounts set up for our new committers.
Cheers
On 04/04/07, William A. Rowe, Jr. [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
Jean T. Anderson wrote:
huh? The
On 29/03/07, robert burrell donkin [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
On 3/29/07, Craig L Russell [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
Hi Robert,
From my reading of the incubator PPMC guide, the guide only talks
about the process up to the point where the PPMC votes to offer
commit privileges to a new member.
Martin Ritchie wrote:
Thanks for this discussion. So just to clarify, anyone on the PPMC can
request the account/karma setup just the IPMC needs to be CC'd as well
as the usual PPMC on the root email.
infra only acknowledges requests from the PMC chair (iPMC chair in this
case). For
William A. Rowe, Jr. wrote:
Martin Ritchie wrote:
Thanks for this discussion. So just to clarify, anyone on the PPMC can
request the account/karma setup just the IPMC needs to be CC'd as well
as the usual PPMC on the root email.
infra only acknowledges requests from the PMC chair (iPMC
On Apr 4, 2007, at 10:03 AM, Jean T. Anderson wrote:
William A. Rowe, Jr. wrote:
Martin Ritchie wrote:
Thanks for this discussion. So just to clarify, anyone on the
PPMC can
request the account/karma setup just the IPMC needs to be CC'd as
well
as the usual PPMC on the root email.
Jean T. Anderson wrote:
huh? The instructions [1] say The project PMC needs to send an email to
root. It doesn't say the project PMC chair. Since root can easily
verify pmc members from committee-info.txt [2], I don't see why any
member of the PMC cannot submit the request.
Whoops :) The
On 3/29/07, Craig L Russell [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
Hi Robert,
From my reading of the incubator PPMC guide, the guide only talks
about the process up to the point where the PPMC votes to offer
commit privileges to a new member. It then links to the PMC document
that Martin refers to.
now
The qpid project voted three new members to their project. I was just
following the New Committer info on :
http://apache.org/dev/pmc.html#newcommitter
and noticed:
If you are acting on behalf of a project which was accepted for
incubation, please get in touch with the sponsoring PMC and let
On 3/28/07, Martin Ritchie [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
The qpid project voted three new members to their project. I was just
following the New Committer info on :
http://apache.org/dev/pmc.html#newcommitter
and noticed:
If you are acting on behalf of a project which was accepted for
incubation,
Hi Robert,
From my reading of the incubator PPMC guide, the guide only talks
about the process up to the point where the PPMC votes to offer
commit privileges to a new member. It then links to the PMC document
that Martin refers to.
It's not documented in the PMC document how to apply
I'd have to say that it's the mentors who need to ask for accounts and
grant karma (or get someone else to grant karma).
thanks,
dims
On 3/28/07, Craig L Russell [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
Hi Robert,
From my reading of the incubator PPMC guide, the guide only talks
about the process up to the
19 matches
Mail list logo
