Re: Community readiness-when does it show?

2009-06-24 Thread Martijn Dashorst
On Wed, Jun 24, 2009 at 5:42 AM, J Aaron Farrfa...@apache.org wrote: If a community meets all the criteria, but hasn't discovered a new committer (or two) by itself, is the community ready for graduation? If not, how can we—mentors— nudge the community to focus on this thing, without it

Re: Community readiness-when does it show?

2009-06-24 Thread Emmanuel Lecharny
Martijn Dashorst wrote: On Wed, Jun 24, 2009 at 5:42 AM, J Aaron Farrfa...@apache.org wrote: If a community meets all the criteria, but hasn't discovered a new committer (or two) by itself, is the community ready for graduation? If not, how can we—mentors— nudge the community to focus on

Re: Community readiness-when does it show?

2009-06-24 Thread Leo Simons
On Tue, Jun 23, 2009 at 11:08 PM, Martijn Dashorst martijn.dasho...@gmail.com wrote: If a community meets all the criteria, but hasn't discovered a new committer (or two) by itself, is the community ready for graduation? Potentially, yes. Likely, no :-) If not, how can we—mentors— nudge the

Re: Community readiness-when does it show?

2009-06-24 Thread Ross Gardler
2009/6/24 Emmanuel Lecharny elecha...@apache.org Martijn Dashorst wrote: On Wed, Jun 24, 2009 at 5:42 AM, J Aaron Farrfa...@apache.org wrote: If a community meets all the criteria, but hasn't discovered a new committer (or two) by itself, is the community ready for graduation? If not, how

Re: Community readiness-when does it show?

2009-06-24 Thread Scott Comer
i would think that if there is someone contributing to the project that the community would recognize and add them themselves. it isn't up to the mentors to do anything except perhaps suggest they consider it if they're being really thick about it. it would be cool if the mentors might

Re: Community readiness-when does it show?

2009-06-24 Thread Emmanuel Lecharny
Scott Comer wrote: i would think that if there is someone contributing to the project that the community would recognize and add them themselves. it isn't up to the mentors to do anything except perhaps suggest they consider it if they're being really thick about it. A bit too convoluted a

Community readiness-when does it show?

2009-06-23 Thread Martijn Dashorst
When is a community Apache Ready™? According to our exit criteria (iirc): - when the community has performed at least one Apache release - when the community has cleaned the code from all license issues - when the community is diverse and open My current issue is with the definition of open.

Re: Community readiness-when does it show?

2009-06-23 Thread J Aaron Farr
On Wed 24 Jun 2009 06:08, Martijn Dashorst martijn.dasho...@gmail.com wrote: My current issue is with the definition of open. Not necessarily as documented (haven't looked at the text lately), but as a gut feeling: when is a community open? - all (technical) discussions happen on publicly