On Fri, Aug 12, 2005 at 12:04:34PM -0400, Kristian Benoit wrote: > I remember, when I started using Gentoo, reading that portage is a stand > alone tool, it is not bind into Gentoo in anyway, someone could use it > on redhat, debian, lfs... Nice intention, but impossible with stable/alpha code- the abstractions are missing. No config abstractions, but more importantly no format abstractions; no true package object.
> Back then I was using lfs so I thought portage could be the way to go on > lfs, but I realized that Gentoo fit my needs and I did'nt have to > compile everything by hand anymore and still have everything compiled by > my machines :) OH JOY !!! Heh, came via the route I did... > But 5 years or so later, the only official place to get portage releases > is still in the gentoo mirrors. There is no RSS feed or anything like > that. I still believe that portage has the potential to be so powerful > that redhat, debian, ... could be building their packages using portage, > managing their own tree, having night build. > > The problem is see, is that the initial portage vision (or perhaps my > initial vision, a vision I still have) has not been carried along with > it's developpement. The vision got blocked by the implementation. Try busting all of the globals out of portage, then abstracting all ebuild specific actions (doebuild) behind package apis, so that different formats can be swapped on the fly. Hell, binding dbapi and *tree classes together into one, and having them properly inherited from a base is required, rather then lots of duplicated code. From there, how do you represent the *depends of a package, so that the resolver can be reused across different configurations of package format (this box being rpm, that being ebuild fex); need to break it down into restrictions, handing the actual depends matching off to repositories, with the resolver shifting sets of returned packages/restrictions around to build up a graph. Either way, look at gentoo-src/portage/portage and gentoo-src/portage/rewrite-misc Work is underway, help is needed, jump in and start digging :) The design *should* allow for lots of crazy crap, although anyone who sees a flaw please speak up now :) > Having an official web site, doc, ... will help getting visibility and > effort from the rest of the world thus we'll have better tools and > eventually extend portage beyond Gentoo. API for tools, a *sane* api moreso :) ~harring
pgptbc6oHdG5T.pgp
Description: PGP signature
