Re: [Gimp-developer] Suggestion: Make the'Newlayer'commanddefaultto'New lay

2006-05-17 Thread Simon Budig
Martin Nordholts ([EMAIL PROTECTED]) wrote: > >To exaggerate your approach: Wouldn't it be the most usable GIMP if we > >keep counters for the button presses? And if it turns out that a user > >uses SHIFT-Click more than a simple click, shouldn't we just switch the > >behaviour of the button on the

Re: [Gimp-developer] Suggestion: Make the'Newlayer'commanddefaultto'New lay

2006-05-17 Thread Martin Nordholts
What are these "lot of inconsistencies"? I'm sorry, lot is probably a too strong word. Lookup bugzilla entires though, and you'll find that not a negligible amount of them can be considered as inconsistency fixes/enhancements. _

Re: [Gimp-developer] Suggestion: Make the'Newlayer'commanddefaultto'New lay

2006-05-17 Thread Martin Nordholts
Your approach involves a lot of guesswork: We have to make an educated guess, what is the more frequent usage of each of the dozends of buttons. Each user has to guess what we guessed. And I bet that there are users out there who don't agree with our guesses. How do we defend our guesses? First

Re: [Gimp-developer] Suggestion: Make the'Newlayer'commanddefaultto'New lay

2006-05-17 Thread Martin Nordholts
Have a look at most recent Inkscape or read http://wiki.inkscape.org/wiki/index.php/ReleaseNotes. Calligraphic pen and Pen tool now use same modifiers other tools use. This is both "in the sense of effective workflow" and "in the structured sense", because it gives consistent experience throughout