Re: [GNC] Strange reconciliation behavior

2020-04-12 Thread Christopher Lam
As others have reported, this change was *meant* to be more strict in interpretation of reconcile *statement_date* (which eventually becomes the split's *reconciled date*). My suspicion is that your first successful reconciliation used an incorrect *statement_date* which led to the second reconcili

Re: [GNC] Strange reconciliation behavior

2020-04-12 Thread David Carlson
Please reply to the list or use reply all On Sun, Apr 12, 2020, 5:22 PM Art Chimes wrote: > David, > Thanks for the quick reply. I will see what others have to say before > I decide whether to go forward or revert! > > Meantime, I'll peruse the developers' mailing list to see what I can learn. >

Re: [GNC] Strange reconciliation behavior

2020-04-12 Thread David Cousens
Art, Are you using GnuCash V3.9 If you are please either revert to 3.8 or upgrade to the newly released 3.10 version which reverts changes in 3.9 if the following is causing your problem. The problem I encountered in 3.9 was that the starting balance did not include reconciled transactions which

Re: [GNC] Strange reconciliation behavior

2020-04-12 Thread David Carlson
There is a big discussion going on in the developer arena about what is wrong with the reconciliation process in release 3.9 I suspect that you may being an artifact of that. They have released 3.10 in an attempt to fix that, but if you are conservative you may want to revert to 3.8 instead. Per

[GNC] Strange reconciliation behavior

2020-04-12 Thread Art Chimes
Strange to me, anyway. I have a long-closed U.S. mutual fund account (call it ABCDX) that was never reconciled since I started using GnuCash a year ago. Now I want to reconcile it, and I'm tackling it year-by-year. I reconciled the first year closing balance, 5,898.936 shares, without issue. Pro