Kindred Issues in Kindred Fora: Open Source Software

2002-01-06 Thread Bernard Lang
One issue for computer scientists is that, to a significant extent, their literature is composed of programs. The interest of free software (free as in freedom, to do what you please with it) is that it can be improved and built upon, exactly the way one does for mathematical theories or proofs, or

Re: Is The Feel of Paper Immortal?

2002-01-06 Thread Jim Till
A clarification: the prediction referred to by Stevan was made by Richard Smith, the editor of the BMJ (and, I believe, the chief executive of the BMJ Publishing Group?) not by me. I'll attach an excerpt of the entire paragraph, so that the context for his prediction may become more apparent. My

Re: Is The Feel of Paper Immortal?

2002-01-06 Thread Stevan Harnad
On Sun, 6 Jan 2002, Jim Till wrote: > http://bmj.com/cgi/content/full/324/7328/5 > > [rs]> The web has advantages of speed, reach, interactivity, > [rs]> and infinite space, but paper has the advantages of > [rs]> readability, portability, and attractiveness. The > [rs]> future is not "paper or el

Re: Is The Feel of Paper Immortal?

2002-01-06 Thread Jim Till
The threads about access, dissemination, peer-review costs and preservation raise another issue: what about the future of journals? There's a comment about this in the Jan. 5 issue of the electronic version of BMJ (freely accessible, via: http://bmj.com/cgi/content/full/324/7328/5 ). The BMJ: mov

Re: What exactly is the digital preservation problem?

2002-01-06 Thread Barry Mahon
David Goodman wrote: > > It would seem to me much more practical from an economic and technical > standpoint to simply archive all scientific publications, including the > marginal ones, than to prepare > > > content extractions (by the authors > > or experts) written with the aim at being concise

Re: What exactly is the digital preservation problem?

2002-01-06 Thread David Goodman
It would seem to me much more practical from an economic and technical standpoint to simply archive all scientific publications, including the marginal ones, than to prepare > content extractions (by the authors > or experts) written with the aim at being concise, full content, > understandable i