Re: Author Publication Charge Debate

2004-02-10 Thread Albert Henderson
on 2/6/2004 Jean-Claude Guédon wrote: I believe Stevan has said most of what is needed to answer your message. For my part, I will focus on OA journals and would like to underscore the fact that this particular way to move to open access will require some concertation among a variety of

Re: Author Publication Charge Debate

2004-02-10 Thread Jean-Claude Guédon
In response to Albert Henderson, let me stress the following points: 1. The trend I was referring to was the growing support of a growing number of various granting agencies for financial support for the OA business plan as exemplified by BioMed Central and by PLos; 2. If we look at the

Meeting: National Policies on Open Access Provision for University Research Output

2004-02-10 Thread Steve Hitchcock
We are pleased to announce the programme for the meeting National Policies on Open Access (OA) Provision for University Research Output http://opcit.eprints.org/feb19prog.html

Re: Author Publication Charge Debate

2004-02-10 Thread Suhail A. R.
Jean-Claude Guedon wrote: 3. The OA [journal] movement may be commercial, but it does not have to be. Comparing it to a dot.com is inaccurate at best; Can you please tell us why? 4. If there is one way to increase scientific productivity, it is with open access. Impact figures that begin to

Re: Author Publication Charge Debate

2004-02-10 Thread Stevan Harnad
I will not be replying further to A. Henderson or A.R. Suhail on the Author Publication Charge Debate, for two reasons: (1) Direct spokesmen for PLoS, BMC, and the Developing World are better qualified to reply. (2) The flavor of OA to which I am devoting most of my own energy

OAI compliant personal pages

2004-02-10 Thread Jim Till
On Tue, 10 Feb 2004, Jean-Claude Guédon wrote [in part]: [j-cg] 2. If we look at the growing number of open access [j-cg] journals and the growing number of open access [j-cg] repositories, including OAI compliant personal [j-cg] pages, and if we look at OA harvesters, I would say [j-cg] that

Setting up an institutional archive: some experiences

2004-02-10 Thread Eriksson J=F6rgen
Dear all, There has been some discussion earlier about the estimated cost for institutional archives. We will give a summary of how we have approched the task of setting up an institutional archive, some of our experiences and costs related to that work.We also hope this might stimulate others

Re: Author Publication Charge Debate

2004-02-10 Thread Fytton Rowland
I believe that paid-for secondary services like Chemical Abstracts *will* have a place in the new world of OA. I am not convinced that give-away software from OAI or wherever will do the whole job of search and navigation through the literature. However, Stevan has always said that his arguments

Re: Author Publication Charge Debate

2004-02-10 Thread Albert Henderson
on Tue, 10 Feb 2004 Jean-Claude =?iso-8859-1?q?Gu=E9don?= jean.claude.gue...@umontreal.ca wrote: In response to Albert Henderson, let me stress the following points: 1. The trend I was referring to was the growing support of a growing number of various granting agencies for financial support

Re: Setting up an institutional archive: some experiences

2004-02-10 Thread Thomas Krichel
Eriksson Jörgen writes We are very interested in getting in touch with other institutional archives to share experiences on ways of implementing an institutional archive. Please send comments and your experiences either to the list or directly to us. There is a special mailing list for

Re: Author Publication Charge Debate

2004-02-10 Thread Thomas Krichel
Fytton Rowland writes I believe that paid-for secondary services like Chemical Abstracts *will* have a place in the new world of OA. Some may have, others won't have. Building collections of secondary data is what the OAI-PMH protocol is all about. If the full-text is free, it is more

Re: OAI compliant personal pages

2004-02-10 Thread Tim Brody
Jim Till wrote: On Tue, 10 Feb 2004, Jean-Claude Guédon wrote [in part]: [j-cg] the growing number of open access repositories [j-cg] including OAI compliant personal pages I noted with interest Jean-Claude's comment about OAI compliant personal pages. How can such pages be identified as

Re: Author Publication Charge Debate

2004-02-10 Thread Albert Henderson
on Tue, 10 Feb 2004 Stevan Harnad har...@ecs.soton.ac.uk wrote: [snip] It does seem ironic, though, that a spokesman on behalf of the developing world (ARS) should be making common cause with a publicist for toll-access publishers (AH) who has long argued that the solution to the serials

Re: Author Publication Charge Debate

2004-02-10 Thread Jean-Claude Guédon
See comments below: Le 10 Février 2004 11:17, Albert Henderson a écrit : on Tue, 10 Feb 2004 Jean-Claude =?iso-8859-1?q?Gu=E9don?= jean.claude.gue...@umontreal.ca wrote: In response to Albert Henderson, let me stress the following points: 1. The trend I was referring to was the growing