[GOAL] Re: [sparc-oaforum] Re: Cancelling because contents are Green OA vs. because publisher allows Green OA -- A practical evaluation of library workflow

2013-09-17 Thread Ellen Finnie Duranceau
With this debate underway, I've been trying to picture a reasonable workflow that would assess the rate of immediate green OA via publisher's self-archiving policy and use it effectively in a collections process. I have been unable to come up with any scenario that seems solid enough to even

[GOAL] Re: [sparc-oaforum] Re: Cancelling because contents are Green OA vs. because publisher allows Green OA -- A practical evaluation of library workflow

2013-09-17 Thread Heather Morrison
Good points, Ellen. One to add, inspired by Rick: high-cost journals tend to be part of big deals. Even if a library did all this work to identify journals with free content, publishers would not decrease the cost of the big deal and if libraries try to cancel the big deal, Rick's experience

[GOAL] Re: [sparc-oaforum] Re: Cancelling because contents are Green OA vs. because publisher allows Green OA -- A practical evaluation of library workflow

2013-09-17 Thread Rick Anderson
Ellen, the very detailed and time-intensive process you outline below is one that would arguably be necessary in order to perform an ongoing, comprehensive analysis of article availability under a Green OA regime, but I think it's much more than would be necessary in order to make reasonable