Re: http://text-e.org/debats/
A-Priori Peer Review vs. A-Posteriori Review and Commentary (on
Peer-Reviewed Research)
Stevan Harnad
The function of peer review (refereeing) in research publication is
both to shape and to label the quality of published research. It is
a dynamic process, involving
The shortage for post-graduate researchers, practitioners,
and policy makers is in state-of-the-art reviews that are
comprehensive and authoritative. For instance, the standards
of many medical journals for reporting expensive clinical
trials (CONSORT) recomm
Sorry:
http://www.els.net/
At 12:22 PM 2001-06-13 +0100, you wrote:
The shortage for post-graduate researchers, practitioners,
and policy makers is in state-of-the art reviews ...
Albert Henderson
<70244.1...@compuserve.com>
The need for reviews is well appreciated by those producing modern on-line
and
The last few years has seen the remarkable success of a number of
review journals from different publishers: The "Current Opinion in ..."
and the "Trends in ..." series from Current Biology (now Elsevier), and
now the Nature reviews (at a somewhat lower level of intelle
