Hi Gilbert,
Mehta's review is the first review of Edna's "Holy Warriors". The
"praiseworthy review" what you are talking about is from the publisher's
site. As you know, all publishers will carry praise-worthy comments
about their product on their site; it is in their interest to sell the
book a
Hi George,
As usual, you get so base in your response and personal attacks. I hope your
post does not reflect where your mind is!
Do I owe Avelino an apology?
Yes I did think he wrote the review. And I noticed Mario made the same
judgement call, and very likely Victor.
I did apologize to Aveli
Hi Gilbert,
You cannot write about Goan ayatollahs, wading in boots through some Goan posts
and write
negatively of "Goan character" and not expect a taste of your own medicine. I
am glad you made an
apology to the good Avelino.
Regards,
George
_
D
Hi Gilbert
I am a bit surprised that having been caught with your fly open in cyberspace,
you did not choose
to publicly apologize to Avelino after assuming he wrote a less than flattering
review of Edna
Fernandes' book. He did not write the review and your comments should have been
withdrawn.
Re: Review on "Holy Warriors" by Edna Fernandes
Victor makes several important points. I have not read the original book. Yet
as Victor points out, I have written books, non-scientific and scientific
articles, which have been published. Hence, I have dealt with many reviewers
and commentator
