Re: [Goanet]Re: Cafeteria Catholics and Gay Penguins

2005-05-02 Thread Marlon Menezes
Fr. Ivo, Thank you for taking the time to respond. If you feel that science is based on unverifiable opinion and unsubstantiated facts, I dont belive this discussion will go very far. Science is obviously not perfect, which is why it promotes an environment for healthy debate and self correction.

Re: [Goanet]Re: Cafeteria Catholics

2005-05-02 Thread Mervyn Lobo
"Fr. Ivo Da C. Souza" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > The facts only reveal our human frailty. We are > sinners. We need God's > redemption. The bishops find it difficult to cope up > with the problem. It is also money racket. > Paedophilia is a crime. We have to learn the > measures that are to be

RE: [Goanet]Re: Cafeteria Catholics - Nasci

2005-05-02 Thread Mervyn Lobo
Nasci Caldeira <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > It is the 'order of nature'; like Fr Ivo says; it's > not antiquated religious > dogma; religion is only accepting the truth! For > heaven's sake, Santosh, you > and scientists and agnostics like you have a lot to > learn, in this field. > Santosh, I t

RE: [Goanet]Re: Cafeteria Catholics

2005-05-02 Thread Nasci Caldeira
d News" as in the Gospels. "I am the way, the truth and the Life"; You should believe again in all this! Better than other false gods! Amen. No bad wishes, Marlon. Just good friendly advise! Cheers! Nasci Caldeira Melbourne. From: Marlon Menezes <[EMAIL PROTECTED] >Reply-To

Re: [Goanet]Re: Cafeteria Catholics

2005-05-02 Thread Venantius J Pinto
Reasonably said Gabe. I did not much to say so far but wish to say a bit on the points you raise. I personally feel that no one should impose their sexuality or sense of it onto others- whether they be hetero or homosexual. But it is regarded as freedom to be able to do so. Sapiens and transient be

Re: [Goanet]Re: Cafeteria Catholics

2005-05-02 Thread Gabe Menezes
I find it difficult to fault Homosexuals and gays, as long as they do not impose their sexuality on others. This is something we have to accommodate and not be insensitive to. Any family can have offspring that turn out this way. What would the opinion of our Conservatives on hermaphrodites be? Kil

RE: [Goanet]Re: Cafeteria Catholics

2005-05-02 Thread Marlon Menezes
What Fr. Ivo is stating is just opinion. Currently there is no definitive scientific evidence that indicates that homo-sexuality is socio-cultural or is endemic to a certain fraction of the human population. The simplistic opinions of the church that has been wrong on so many issues cannot be rel

RE: [Goanet]Re: Cafeteria Catholics

2005-05-01 Thread Nasci Caldeira
Hi all, Well said, Fr. Ivo; Santosh Helekar, please take note! We as a society do not condemn these aberrations, but we do not accept these as normal; hence the need to help these sick persons. This type of help should not be construed as acceptance of something against the 'human nature/order',

Re: [Goanet]Re: Cafeteria Catholics

2005-05-01 Thread Mervyn Lobo
"Fr. Ivo Da C. Souza" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > I do not deny the facts. I have affirmed that > homosexuality is wrong. Yet the > priests have to be helped. The problem boils down to > what I have said: Let us do something for them... Fr. Ivo da C.Souza, Parishioners have been doing their le

Re: [Goanet]Re: Cafeteria Catholics

2005-05-01 Thread Mervyn Lobo
"Fr. Ivo Da C. Souza" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > I have a quick answer: there should not be > "homosexual Catholic priests", but if there are, > as the media are publicizing, then homosexuality > does not cease to be "an aberration", "abnormal". Fr. Ivo da C. Souza, Here in N. America, its e

Re: [Goanet]Re: Cafeteria Catholics

2005-04-29 Thread halur rasho
Homosexuality is certainly not abnormal to homosexuals? --- "Fr. Ivo Da C. Souza" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > "Fr. Ivo Da C. Souza" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > >> 3. Do you believe homosexuality is evil? > > Homosexuality is an aberration. It is abnormal. > > Father Ivo, > I have a quick questi

Re: [Goanet]Re: Cafeteria Catholics & women priests

2005-04-28 Thread rene barreto
Victor, Good one ! But who are those ? .. * SOME OF US * let .7000 plus or so , tell us. rene --- [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: > Here we are again, fellow Goanetters, not discussing > issues that raised > so much heat and dust in the past, and once again >

Re: [Goanet]Re: Cafeteria Catholics & women priests

2005-04-28 Thread vrangelrib
Here we are again, fellow Goanetters, not discussing issues that raised so much heat and dust in the past, and once again some of us are throwing dirt at the others. "You are this" and "You are that" and who knows what else. When will some of us ever stop throwing stones at other people? F

Re: [Goanet]Re: Cafeteria Catholics & women priests

2005-04-27 Thread Mario Goveia
George, You, too, need to relax and let me find out the official reasons, if any, before continuing this drumbeat of accusations. Since when did you become such an expert on Catholic doctrine and practice that you "know" everything with such certainty? If your mind is closed, that is quite anothe

Re: [Goanet]Re: Cafeteria Catholics and Cafeteria Goans

2005-04-26 Thread Mario Goveia
Gabe, You need to relax and lighten up a little. Chill, bro', as we say in the hood. First of all, though I am a huge Bush-supporter and worked to elect and re-elect him in my battleground state of Ohio, I don't recall taking any offense at postings ridiculing him, unless you are translating my c

Re: [Goanet]Re: Cafeteria Catholics and Cafeteria Goans

2005-04-26 Thread Gabe Menezes
On 25/04/05, Mario Goveia <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > I don't have the answer to your question about > fractions, Marlon. I recently agreed with George that > even Papa Ratzi is a cafeteria Catholic at some level. RESPONSE: You took offence to people's postings denigrating George Bush WRT to his

Re: [Goanet]Re: Cafeteria Catholics and Cafeteria Goans

2005-04-25 Thread Mario Goveia
I don't have the answer to your question about fractions, Marlon. I recently agreed with George that even Papa Ratzi is a cafeteria Catholic at some level. I believe practicing Catholics unconsciously use the standards of "on balance" and "baby and bathwater", and use the tenets of the Church and

Re: [Goanet]Re: Cafeteria Catholics and Cafeteria Goans

2005-04-24 Thread Marlon Menezes
This is exactly the point I am trying to make. What fraction of the self proclaimed "true catholics" actually practice or believe in all the tenants of their religion. Heck, what fraction of the clergy do the same? (I am assuming that child molestation is not one of required tasks of the clergy!)

Re: [Goanet]Re: Cafeteria Catholics and Cafeteria Goans

2005-04-24 Thread Mario Goveia
In a recent post I asked a simple question that NO ONE ANSWERED. The question was, "Is there anyone out there who is NOT a cafeteria Catholic at some level? Just curious." Does Gilbert's complex epistle defending "non-cafeteria" Catholics mean that he would answer my question above with a firm,

Re: [Goanet]Re: Cafeteria Catholics and Cafeteria Goans

2005-04-24 Thread Gabe Menezes
On 23/04/05, George Pinto <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > Santosh > > Catholic practice and teaching has changed over times at the Papacy level. > Does it mean the > present Pope is a cafeteria Catholic too?.. The right-wing fundamentalists would like us to believe that Church h

Re: [Goanet]Re: Cafeteria Catholics and Cafeteria Goans

2005-04-23 Thread Mario Goveia
Yes, George, the Pope is also a cafeteria Catholic, in my never-humble opinion. As I asked in another post, is there anyone out there WHO ISN'T, at some level? And, NO, George, the Catholic Church has NOT been "one unbroken chain of constant practices." The way I see it one has three choices, 1)