This is another view which shows how Shourie dealt with the Tatas. http://www.outlookindia.com/article.aspx?270930
The Chakra Of Deceit 1. VSNL sold by NDA government in 2002. Tatas given several favours. 2. 773 acres of prime land held as surplus should have been demerged 3. Tatas create several problems in the proposed separation of the land from VSNL 4. Tata writes to Shourie suggesting land be given to VSNL after payment of a nominal price