[Goanet] WILL ENGLISH MOI CREATE A PARADIGM SHIFT IN GOAN POLITICS?

2011-06-30 Thread SOTER
Perfect questions by Marshall. Very surprising that secular torch bearers are quiet on Rajendra's claims of a communal polarisation. When we raised the same fears some days earlier our concerns about religious discrimination and persecution of minorities were considered primarily those of loud

[Goanet] WILL ENGLISH MOI CREATE A PARADIGM SHIFT IN GOAN POLITICS?

2011-06-29 Thread Marshall Mendonza
*Rajendra Kakodkar:* It was the Diocesan Society which mooted the idea of government grants to English MoI. Their motivation came from the fact that the catholic community was preferring private English schools in preference to church run Konkani schools, a genuine reason. The PTAs of the

[Goanet] WILL ENGLISH MOI CREATE A PARADIGM SHIFT IN GOAN POLITICS?

2011-06-28 Thread SOTER
Foxy arguments below aren't they? Looks like the prowling fox is throwing mining dust in our eyes and shedding innocent looking tears. Sorry, some of us are not born today. That the demand for English MoI came from a small section of coastal people dominated by catholics and Church run

[Goanet] WILL ENGLISH MOI CREATE A PARADIGM SHIFT IN GOAN POLITICS?

2011-06-28 Thread Freddy Fernandes
In response to: Message: 1 Date: Tue, 28 Jun 2011 00:18:42 +0530 (IST) From: rajendra kakodkar rskakod...@yahoo.co.in To: goanet@lists.goanet.org Subject: [Goanet] WILL ENGLISH MOI CREATE A PARADIGM SHIFT IN GOAN POLITICS? Dear Rajendra Politicians not only in Goa but all over India

Re: [Goanet] WILL ENGLISH MOI CREATE A PARADIGM SHIFT IN GOAN POLITICS?

2011-06-28 Thread floriano
1. The hullabaloo that is ongoing with ENGLISH as the medium of instruction is nothing but a massive effort to SAVE MARATHI in GOA. 2. The Marathiwadas had it going for them at the cost of Konkani, the GOA's mother tongue, since time immemorial, even with the Portuguese blessing Marathi over

[Goanet] WILL ENGLISH MOI CREATE A PARADIGM SHIFT IN GOAN POLITICS? -FALACIES, CONTRADICTIONS COVER UP

2011-06-28 Thread SOTER
Falacy No 1: Their motivation came from the fact that the catholic community was preferring private English schools in preference to church run Konkani schools, a genuine reason. Falacy No: 2 But unfortunately it happened just a year before the scheduled legislative assembly elections. It

[Goanet] WILL ENGLISH MOI CREATE A PARADIGM SHIFT IN GOAN POLITICS?

2011-06-27 Thread rajendra kakodkar
  It was the Diocesan Society which mooted the idea of government grants to English MoI. Their motivation came from the fact that the catholic community was preferring private English schools in preference to church run Konkani schools, a genuine reason. The PTAs of the church run schools toed

Re: [Goanet] WILL ENGLISH MOI CREATE A PARADIGM SHIFT IN GOAN POLITICS?

2011-06-27 Thread Frederick FN Noronha फ्रेडरिक नोरोन्या *فريدريك نورونيا
Dear Rajendra, This is a clever argument! I read you saying: if you get your demands met, you will face a communal backlash! Heads we win, and tails you lose. Earlier too, around 1985-87, support was garnered for Konkani by suggesting that Marathi would swallow the minorities... Now we can see