Again Eli Wise's comments make me think that he has not read the book.
He asks, "If the book was supposed to give a picture of the pain and
difficulties that Israeli and Palestinian children have as a result
of the conflict why is it necessary to give the impression that a
Palestinian child find
Dear Linda,
In my second message to the list which was posted on March 6, I
quoted your review in its *entirety* - I even commented on some of
what you say in the first paragraph. If you missed it, I'll be happy
to forward a copy to you. In my more recent message about Anne
Dublin's review, pos
Bernard Katz does not quote the first paragraph of my review of
Three Wishes in which, like Anne Dublin, I pointed out the problems
with the book. It says in part: "
The Canadian author of this book brings to it assumptions that will
set off alarm bells. One is that the United Nations is an
--- Message requiring your approval --
From: Bernard Katz <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
Subject: [ha-Safran]: Re: Three Wishes
Dear Safranim,
Please forgive yet another long posting from me.
I'm sorry to say that my colleague and friend
Anne Dubli
With all due respect, I would like to ask Eli Wise if he has read
this book, or whether he's reacting and dashing off in a direction he thinks
is correct simply because the Canadian Jewish Congress has issued some
statements about it? Was the CJC in fact correct in its assessment?
This book actua
With all due respect, I would like to ask Eli Wise if he has read
this book, or whether he's reacting and dashing off in a direction he thinks
is correct simply because the Canadian Jewish Congress has issued some
statements about it? Was the CJC in fact correct in its assessment?
This book actua
Before I proceed with yet another long posting, a disclosure. I am an
honourary life member of the Ontario Library Association (founded in
1900 and the largest library association in Canada with 5,300
members), as a result of having been given one of the two inaugural
Distinguished Service Awar
7 matches
Mail list logo
