Thanks all the folks participating this discussion and providing valuable
suggestions and options.
I suggest we take it forward to make a proposal in Apache Commons community.
Thanks,
Haifeng
-Original Message-
From: Chen, Haifeng [mailto:haifeng.c...@intel.com]
Sent: Friday
but this instance seems reasonable to
me. -C
[1] https://apr.apache.org/
> On 2/3/16, 6:46 PM, "Chen, Haifeng" wrote:
>
>>Thanks Chris.
>>
>>>> I went through the repository, and now understand the reasoning
>>>>that would locate this code
cessful as an independent project or stalls,
>>>> Hadoop and/or Spark and/or $project will have to reabsorb it as
>>>> maintainers. Projects have high mortality in early life, and a
>>>> fight over inheritance/maintenance is something we'd like to avoid.
&g
Thanks Allen for your questioning.
>> Why is this discussion taking place on hdfs-dev when other parts of Hadoop
>> use encryption code? That alone makes me uncomfortable moving this code
>> outside of the Hadoop umbrella.
Let me explain in this way. Hadoop common implements the crypto stuff
gt; >>>Colin
> >>>
> >>>On Tue, Feb 2, 2016 at 12:29 AM, Chris Douglas
> >>>
> >>>wrote:
> >>>> As a subproject of Hadoop, Chimera could maintain its own cadence.
> >>>> There's also no reason why it should maintain
plicated pedigree. If Chimera
> eventually becomes a TLP, it seems fair to include those who work on
> it while it is a subproject. Declared upfront, that criterion is
> fairer than any post hoc justification, and will lead to a more
> accurate account of its community than a subs
Thanks to all folks providing feedbacks and participating the discussions.
@Owen, do you still have any concerns on going forward in the direction of
Apache Commons (or other options, TLP)?
Thanks,
Haifeng
-Original Message-
From: Chen, Haifeng [mailto:haifeng.c...@intel.com]
Sent
>> I believe encryption is becoming a core part of Hadoop. I think that
>> moving core components out of Hadoop is bad from a project management
>> perspective.
> Although it's certainly true that encryption capabilities (in HDFS, YARN,
> etc.) are becoming core to Hadoop, I don't think that sh
Thanks all folks for providing valuable feedbacks.
Uma, would you help a proposal to Apache Commons for Chimera to join as a
module, mentioning that Hadoop and Spark are both on board to depend on this?
Thanks,
Haifeng
-Original Message-
From: Chen, Haifeng [mailto:haifeng.c
> [Kai] So far I saw it's mainly about AES-256. I suggest the scope can be
> expanded a little bit, perhaps a dedicated high performance encryption
> library, then we would have quite much to contribute to it, like other
> ciphers, MACs, PRNGs and so on. Then both Hadoop and Spark can benefit fr
Agree that if making Chimera part of Apache commons is the desire, it would be
better to be a standalone component in commons with its own release traces.
>From apache commons project web (https://commons.apache.org/), we see there is
>already a long list of components in its Apache Commons Prope
11 matches
Mail list logo
