Re: [DISCUSSION] Create a branch to work on non-blocking access to HDFS

2018-05-31 Thread Stack
Just to close the loop, I just made a branch named HDFS-13572 to match the new non-blocking issue (after some nice encouragement posted up on the JIRA). Thanks, S On Tue, May 15, 2018 at 9:30 PM, Stack wrote: > On Fri, May 4, 2018 at 5:47 AM, Anu Engineer > wrote: > >> Hi Stack, >> >> >> >>

Re: [DISCUSSION] Create a branch to work on non-blocking access to HDFS

2018-05-15 Thread Stack
On Fri, May 4, 2018 at 5:47 AM, Anu Engineer wrote: > Hi Stack, > > > > Why don’t we look at the design of what is being proposed? Let us post > the design to HDFS-9924 and then if needed, by all means let us open a new > Jira. > > That will make it easy to understand

Re: [DISCUSSION] Create a branch to work on non-blocking access to HDFS

2018-05-03 Thread Anu Engineer
Hi Stack, Why don’t we look at the design of what is being proposed? Let us post the design to HDFS-9924 and then if needed, by all means let us open a new Jira. That will make it easy to understand the context if someone is looking at HDFS-9924. I personally believe that it should be the

Re: [DISCUSSION] Create a branch to work on non-blocking access to HDFS

2018-05-03 Thread Duo Zhang
Will prepare a design doc soon to roughly describe the things we want to do and how we plan to do it, and also the undecided things, such as how to support fan-out. Thanks. 2018-05-04 4:54 GMT+08:00 Anu Engineer : > Hi St.ack/Wei-Chiu, > > It is very kind of St.Ack to

Re: [DISCUSSION] Create a branch to work on non-blocking access to HDFS

2018-05-03 Thread Anu Engineer
Hi St.ack/Wei-Chiu, It is very kind of St.Ack to bring this question to HDFS Dev. I think this is a good feature to have. As for the branch question, HDFS-9924 branch is already open, we could just use that and I am +1 on adding Duo as a branch committer. I am not familiar with HBase code

Re: [DISCUSSION] Create a branch to work on non-blocking access to HDFS

2018-05-03 Thread Wei-Chiu Chuang
Given that HBase 2 uses async output by default, the way that code is maintained today in HBase is not sustainable. That piece of code should be maintained in HDFS. I am +1 as a participant in both communities. On Thu, May 3, 2018 at 9:14 AM, Stack wrote: > Ok with you lot if

[DISCUSSION] Create a branch to work on non-blocking access to HDFS

2018-05-03 Thread Stack
Ok with you lot if a few of us open a branch to work on a non-blocking HDFS client? Intent is to finish up the old issue "HDFS-9924 [umbrella] Nonblocking HDFS Access". On the foot of this umbrella JIRA is a proposal by the heavy-lifter, Duo Zhang. Over in HBase, we have a limited async DFS