Re: [hibernate-dev] Move Search to a multi-module build

2010-02-12 Thread Steve Ebersole
In my experience with Maven, there is no such thing as a "minor change" :) On Fri, 2010-02-12 at 12:12 -0300, Hardy Ferentschik wrote: > As much as I see the potential of gradle I don't want to be the one to > push this forward > right now. A multi-module setup is a minor change in this case. >

Re: [hibernate-dev] Move Search to a multi-module build

2010-02-12 Thread Hardy Ferentschik
As much as I see the potential of gradle I don't want to be the one to push this forward right now. A multi-module setup is a minor change in this case. --Hardy On Fri, 12 Feb 2010 11:57:17 -0300, Steve Ebersole wrote: > Might I suggest y'all look at gradle since this is something you re ju

Re: [hibernate-dev] Move Search to a multi-module build

2010-02-12 Thread Emmanuel Bernard
Ahahah I am a big believer in Ricardian's competitive advantage. In this theory, Maven and I are on a different side of the fence. Emmanuel On 12 févr. 2010, at 15:55, Hardy Ferentschik wrote: > It seems to me that there are potential other benefits we could gain from a > multi-module > setup.

Re: [hibernate-dev] Move Search to a multi-module build

2010-02-12 Thread Steve Ebersole
Might I suggest y'all look at gradle since this is something you re just getting ready to start? On Fri, 2010-02-12 at 11:55 -0300, Hardy Ferentschik wrote: > It seems to me that there are potential other benefits we could gain from > a multi-module > setup. > > Maybe Emmanuel should actually d

Re: [hibernate-dev] Move Search to a multi-module build

2010-02-12 Thread Emmanuel Bernard
Solr is not a good use case. We should have make it mandatory in the first place. Anyway, we probably need multiple modules in the future but here is the caveat: - in an ideal world we would split hsearch-core from hsearch-hibernate but people will then be forced to put these two dependencies t

Re: [hibernate-dev] Move Search to a multi-module build

2010-02-12 Thread Hardy Ferentschik
It seems to me that there are potential other benefits we could gain from a multi-module setup. Maybe Emmanuel should actually do it, since he loves maven so much ;-) On Fri, 12 Feb 2010 11:46:32 -0300, Sanne Grinovero wrote: > it's ok for me; > the best benefit I expect is to split the tes

Re: [hibernate-dev] Move Search to a multi-module build

2010-02-12 Thread Emmanuel Bernard
I exclude it too :) On 12 févr. 2010, at 15:42, Hardy Ferentschik wrote: > Of course it does not offer any additional functionality, but when deployed > as archetype > into the maven repo it allows to "bootstrap" a Search enabled maven project > using the > maven archetype plugin > (http://mav

Re: [hibernate-dev] Move Search to a multi-module build

2010-02-12 Thread Sanne Grinovero
it's ok for me; the best benefit I expect is to split the testssuite and clean that, opening the doors to a performance&stress testsuite. Also the Solr "optional" dependencies should be actually mandatory if you use the analyzerdefs, so this could eventually be moved to a separate search module; t

Re: [hibernate-dev] Move Search to a multi-module build

2010-02-12 Thread Hardy Ferentschik
Of course it does not offer any additional functionality, but when deployed as archetype into the maven repo it allows to "bootstrap" a Search enabled maven project using the maven archetype plugin (http://maven.apache.org/plugins/maven-archetype-plugin). I agree in current setup the quickst

Re: [hibernate-dev] Move Search to a multi-module build

2010-02-12 Thread Emmanuel Bernard
Is the quickstart archetype really needed? On my side, I always exclude it as it goes in my way. On 12 févr. 2010, at 15:25, Hardy Ferentschik wrote: > Hi, > > For HSEARCH-459 I would like to move Search to a multi-module setup > (similar to Validator). > This way the archetype sources will ac

[hibernate-dev] Move Search to a multi-module build

2010-02-12 Thread Hardy Ferentschik
Hi, For HSEARCH-459 I would like to move Search to a multi-module setup (similar to Validator). This way the archetype sources will actually always get compiled and are less likely to get outdated. I think we talked before about potential benefits of having a multi-module build for Search.