Re: [homenet] ISPs using DHCP for individual clients

2020-11-21 Thread Daniel Migault
Thanks for the response Ian, This seems to confirm that assuming per-subscribers responses is something widely deployed. Thanks! Yours, Daniel On Fri, Nov 20, 2020 at 10:57 AM wrote: > Hi Daniel, > > I can’t speak to A), but we have built and tested DHCPv6 infrastructure > using ISC’s Kea

Re: [homenet] ISPs using DHCP for individual clients

2020-11-21 Thread Daniel Migault
Thanks for the response Mikael, In this case, I have the impression the L2 switch uses the MAC address to determine what type of devices is initiating the DHCP request and orient the DHCP request to the appropriated VLN and DHCP server. I suspect that the type of device is determined the OUIs and

Re: [homenet] ISPs using DHCP for individual clients

2020-11-21 Thread Eric Vyncke (evyncke)
Probably, but others, could do it and have a collision (unsure whether those set the U/L bit correctly) -éric -Original Message- From: Mikael Abrahamsson Organization: People's Front Against WWW Date: Saturday, 21 November 2020 at 17:43 To: Eric Vyncke Cc: Daniel Migault , homenet

Re: [homenet] ISPs using DHCP for individual clients

2020-11-21 Thread Mikael Abrahamsson
On Sat, 21 Nov 2020, Eric Vyncke (evyncke) wrote: The idea to identity the kind of devices (hence any QoE) based on MAC address (probably on the OUI part) has work for many years; but, now more and more OS do MAC address randomization (cfr the MADINAS BoF at IETF-109), so, I am afraid that

Re: [homenet] ISPs using DHCP for individual clients

2020-11-21 Thread Eric Vyncke (evyncke)
Hi Mikael, The idea to identity the kind of devices (hence any QoE) based on MAC address (probably on the OUI part) has work for many years; but, now more and more OS do MAC address randomization (cfr the MADINAS BoF at IETF-109), so, I am afraid that this 'easy/smart' technique is a thing of