Hi,
On 6 Jan 2023, at 13:36, Eric Vyncke (evyncke) wrote:
Well-deserved break for the R community, I also took about 10 days off ;-)
More seriously, there was a major rewrite between -18 (the first IESG telechat)
and -25 (yesterday telechat):
Well-deserved break for the R community, I also took about 10 days off ;-)
More seriously, there was a major rewrite between -18 (the first IESG telechat)
and -25 (yesterday telechat):
Hi Eric,
Sorry, the R world closes for 2 weeks over the holiday period :)
I just read the IESG comments now, and your comment that "The flow and the text
(grammar, English) had also a rewrite”, but the diffs from 24 (my review) to 25
(new) are very
minor and the abstract for example still has
Thank you very much Tim for your review for int-dir.
Even if a little too late for the IESG telechat, I am sure that the authors
will take your review in consideration. I personally like your suggestion to
add an appendix section on the deployment/operation timeline.
Regards
-éric
On
Dear authors, dear Homenet WG,
Happy New Year !
As you may have noticed, the I-D was not approved on yesterday telechat.
The IESG was unanimous to say that the latest revision is much more readable
and clearer.
Barring the DNS-directorate and the late GENART reviews (to be addressed at
least
