Re: [Hornlist] bass clef

2009-01-16 Thread Richard V. West
The composers who lived and worked between the "old" and the "future" may have had a dilemma during the transition to new notation. I'm thinking of Johannes Brahms (or perhaps his copyist or publisher). For example, the second horn part (in D) of the Piano Concerto No. 1. The first bar is notat

RE: [Hornlist] bass clef

2009-01-16 Thread John Baumgart
The old composers would have had to mark it "current notation" and "future notation." John Baumgart -Original Message- From: horn-bounces+john.baumgart=comcast@music.memphis.edu [mailto:horn-bounces+john.baumgart=comcast@music.memphis.edu] On Behalf Of Loren Mayhew Sent: Friday, J

RE: [Hornlist] bass clef

2009-01-16 Thread Loren Mayhew
I prefer new notation, but it doesn't really matter which just as long as there is some way to figure out which you are using. It would have been very helpful if the old composers had marked their horn parts with either "old notation" or "new notation." Loren Mayhew lo...@mayhews.us 001 (520) 289-

[Hornlist] Re: Valkanier Anecdotes, c/o of Arthur Goldstein and Jack Berv (by way of a student)

2009-01-16 Thread lsden...@netzero.net
To the Administrator: It seems like I might have misspelled Valkanier in the email I submitted to you earlier today. The correct spelling would be Valkenier. Which means the subject should have read Valkenier Anecdotes, c/o of Arthur Goldstein and Jack Berv (by way of a student) I have correcte

[Hornlist] Re: Valkanier Anecdotes, c/o of Arthur Goldstein and Jack Berv (by way of a student)

2009-01-16 Thread lsden...@netzero.net
To the Administrator: It seems like I might have misspelled Valkanier in the email I submitted to you earlier today. The correct spelling would be Valkenier. Which means the subject should have read Valkenier Anecdotes, c/o of Arthur Goldstein and Jack Berv (by way of a student) I have correcte

[Hornlist] Valkanier Anecdotes, c/o of Arthur Goldstein and Jack Berv (by way of a student)

2009-01-16 Thread lsden...@netzero.net
In regards to Peter Hirsch’s post about sourcing info regarding Willem Valkanier through Arthur Goldstein, I submit the following, which came directly from Arthur himself in a lesson I had with him almost 30 years ago: We were working on slurring octaves and Mr. Goldstein tried to make a point

[Hornlist] Re: Bass Clef

2009-01-16 Thread HORNTRASH
Now, I must be making the informings to you all that what I am always having the preferentialings of is "Old Notation For Alternate Reading of Trebleclef" aka O.N.F.A.R.T. because why should any one of us be having the drudgeries to be making the knowings of two clefs in the first place an