- #hot irc
- List of validation comments for this user
- etc
Pierre
De : Blake Girardot bgirar...@gmail.com
À : HOT hot@openstreetmap.org
Envoyé le : Dimanche 31 août 2014 22h26
Objet : Re: [HOT] Validating TM2 - providing feedback to new mappers
On 8
Severin
I like the ideas here. Essentially, we're talking about calculating and
recording mappers reputation, and then incorporating into handling of
validation.
How did you contribute http://hdyc.neis-one.org/ is one example of
reputation calculation. It's entirely automated. Your suggesting to
Hi Severin,
Sounds like a nice approach. However the first two steps are unneeded
- we can detect new users when they mark squares as done, not via
changeset hashtags. In my experience newcomers often forget to tag
changesets, so your approach would miss many of them - yet we already
know their
- providing feedback to new mappers
Hi Severin,
Sounds like a nice approach. However the first two steps are unneeded
- we can detect new users when they mark squares as done, not via
changeset hashtags. In my experience newcomers often forget to tag
changesets, so your approach would miss many of them
Hi,
gamification seems to be a hot trend lately. My understanding of this
is a clear communication of (community) goals and closing the feedback
cycle to individual contributors. Counting validated squares may be a
good proxy for a user's efficiency. It may not be the most finegrained,
and
To all who have, Thank you for contributing to this thread.
Although I had been mapping for several years before I started mapping
with HOT, I found my needs were similar to those described by others. I
found myself trying to interpret satellite imagery without the benefit
of having visited
Hi,
On the subject of validation.
As someone who now spends most of their mapping time validating, I think
we 'sell' it the wrong way. I only use the validation button in JOSM now
if I think I am going to find something, and generally use the
HOT-Validate paint Style (Well worth trying if
Hi all, I have been a bit quiet, just coming back on line after one month
recovering form a Motor Bike Crash. Seems I am not as invincible as I
thought :)
Nick +1 for your comments, I totally agree. I also think and Opt In or Opt
Out Check Box Please send me comments on the Task for each User, or
There was a discussion several months ago proposing irc like client for
each job. I think embedding synchronous communication for each job is a
good approach to providing real-time feedback to those working on a
specific project/job.
For some prior art, check out MapCraft [0]. Related tickets
On 8/31/2014 10:09 PM, maning sambale wrote:
There was a discussion several months ago proposing irc like client for
each job. I think embedding synchronous communication for each job is a
good approach to providing real-time feedback to those working on a
specific project/job.
For some
10 matches
Mail list logo
