Re: [HOT] Highway=track

2017-12-28 Thread Rupert Allan
Thanks John. Well-Noted. The conventons for roads here in Uganda are well-administrated by us through Ugand Bureau of Statistics, who hope to one day be the first country in the world to do a national census through OSM conventions. We are trying to support them to the utmost with this, by trainin

Re: [HOT] Highway=track

2017-12-28 Thread john whelan
Note to Robert I think you have to divide the mapping into parts. The first is simple instructions that mappers can follow. In HOT in particular we have a huge turnover of mappers and I think for the most part new mappers look at the options presented in iD and chose, I won't say randomly but it

Re: [HOT] Highway=track

2017-12-27 Thread Rupert Allan
Dear All, We are following this discussion on Highways with interest in Uganda. I am awaiting further input on 'service roads' from Uganda Bureau of Statistics and other national and regional bodies with many years of experience, and we are also learning through community field mapping on the grou

Re: [HOT] Highway=track

2017-12-27 Thread john whelan
The first comment is It looks reasonable to me but I'm not the technical authority on this one. Pierre might be better. Second comment is we can invoke a special preset with iD when opened by Task Manager. Realistically the mappers we want to nudge most are those who only map once and have very

Re: [HOT] Highway=track

2017-12-27 Thread Bjoern Hassler
Hi John, dear friends, Just to add that we've been collecting road mapping tips (and other goodies) here on Google slides (in the HOT drive): http://bjohas.de/go/mmintro (see p. 65). We've said this: - Can it be passed by a vehicle? → unclassified (or better) / residential / track (no

Re: [HOT] Highway=track

2017-12-26 Thread john whelan
Apparently iD can be invoked with customised presets. Another item on the TM3 to do list perhaps. Cheerio John On 26 December 2017 at 18:07, yo paseopor wrote: > I think We need some preset for JOSM or customized iD for these HOT custom > project or specific zone configurations. > > Salut i pr

Re: [HOT] Highway=track

2017-12-26 Thread yo paseopor
I think We need some preset for JOSM or customized iD for these HOT custom project or specific zone configurations. Salut i presets (Health and presets) yopaseopor ___ HOT mailing list HOT@openstreetmap.org https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/hot

Re: [HOT] Highway=track

2017-12-21 Thread john whelan
I should have mentioned highway=path as an acceptable alternative. What I do see when validating though is a large number of highways connecting settlements that are labeled tracks many of which look wide enough for a 4 by 4 and these I feel should be labelled something else. Cheerio John On 21

Re: [HOT] Highway=track

2017-12-21 Thread Philippe Verdy
There may be exceptions if the tracks are not praticable at all by vehicles (including motorbikes). They should however not even be tracks but just paths if they are just usable by horses or usable sportively by mountainbikes. Not all houses or even villages are linked by unpaved tracks=minor roads

[HOT] Highway=track

2017-12-21 Thread john whelan
It's come up in the OSMand mailing list that these aren't shown at higher zoom levels. Whilst mapping specifically just for the rendering system is frowned on in this case it is supported by the wiki. If it connects settlements then according to http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Highway_Tag_Afri