Re: NABBLE NOTIFICATION forCopyright Notice: N R M E F 4 N Y N O S (NRMEF4NYNOS)

2007-01-07 Thread Brian E Carpenter
Could we drop the personal comments and rude words please? The delete key is by far the easiest way to deal with drivel. This is so clearly drivel that I hereby ask the sergeants at arms to consider action against [EMAIL PROTECTED] Brian ___ Ietf

Re: Last Call: draft-ietf-opes-smtp-security (Integrity, privacy and security in OPES for SMTP) to Informational RFC

2007-01-07 Thread Eliot Lear
Frank, I'd have to go further than what you wrote. I believe the document should explicitly discuss interactions with DKIM, as that document is in front of the IESG at this time for approval as a Proposed Standard. Many modifications to a message will invalidate a DKIM signature. It may

Re: Tracking resolution of DISCUSSes

2007-01-07 Thread Simon Josefsson
Adrian Farrel [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: By the way, would it be possible for all DISCUSSes and COMMENTs for I-Ds originated by a working group to be *automatically* copied to the mailing list of the working group? The reasons are: - the WG chairs, editors, and interested parties should not

Re: Tracking resolution of DISCUSSes

2007-01-07 Thread Harald Alvestrand
Agreement, but niggles As Spencer has noted, a DISCUSS often passes through several iterations from the time a concern is raised to the time it's clear what has to be discussed with the WG. I think it would make the IESG's work more difficult if every iteration of such DISCUSSes were