Dear ietf,
To better clarify elements within otis-ipv6-email-authent draft, a separate I-D
is focused primarily on DKIM.
http://tools.ietf.org/html/draft-otis-dkim-harmful-00
Regards,
Douglas Otis
Dear IETF,
Sorry for repeating this message, but the proper subject line had not been used.
http://tools.ietf.org/html/draft-otis-dkim-harmful-00
explains why this document should not be supported to proceed as currently
defined.
Feedback on this I-D is welcome.
Regards,
Douglas Otis
Review of: DKIM is Harmful as Specified
I-D: draft-otis-dkim-harmful-00
Reviewed by: D. Crocker
Review Date: 12 May 2013
Summary:
DKIM is in wide use for email operations today; it is currently at
Draft Standard and has been submitted for elevation to full Internet
Dave has already commented on the confusing and rambling nature of this
document, so I'll focus only on the core claim.
In this document, Doug is re-raising an objection that was discussed long
and hard in the DKIM working group during the development of RFC6376. The
archives are still available
