Re: Controlled vs Managed (Re: ASCII diff of ISOC-proposed changes to BCP)

2005-02-14 Thread Bob Kahn
of the document, or otherwise be misleading. The important aspects of the definition of the IAOC and its relationship to the IASA and ISOC are contained in the body of the document. Leslie. Bob Kahn wrote: Leslie, If the IAOC is intended to provide oversight of the activities and actions of ISOC

Re: Controlled vs Managed (Re: ASCII diff of ISOC-proposed changes to BCP)

2005-02-13 Thread Bob Kahn
Leslie, If the IAOC is intended to provide oversight of the activities and actions of ISOC with respect to IETF related matters in the future, then the IAOC will need to be independent of ISOC, otherwise the IAOC cannot be an effective oversight body. You might as well have ISOC be directly

Re: Consensus? IPR rights and all that

2004-12-06 Thread Bob Kahn
Harald, I am enroute back to Washington at the moment, but did want to comment on IP matters. I think it fair to state in the document what the IETF thinks appropriate for it to manage its own affairs going forward, but one of the matters we will have to work out is the fact that there is