Re: Ietf Digest, Vol 21, Issue 63

2006-01-16 Thread Robert Kahn
Patrice, You ask a relevant historical question, so let me try my hand at an answer. The history here is like this. Vint Cerf set up something called the Internet Configuration Control Board (ICCB) in the late 1970s when we were both at DARPA. It was intended to be an informal group that would

Re: IAOC Responsibilities

2005-02-06 Thread Robert Kahn
will choose to establish one if it becomes clear that this is the best construct for the IETF? I do agree that the term "belonging to the IETF" is not the best language to use, given the IETF's decision not to formalize its legal status at this time. H

Re: IAOC Responsibilities

2005-02-06 Thread Robert Kahn
IETF" is not the best language to use, given the IETF's decision not to formalize its legal status at this time. Harald --On 3. februar 2005 07:45 -0500 Robert Kahn <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: I continue to remain concerned that the BCP is not flexible

IAOC Responsibilities

2005-02-03 Thread Robert Kahn
sponsibility for managing IETF assets in the first instance, even if the IAOC were to delegate the day to day administrative tasks such as sublicensing to others (e.g. to the IAD). Bob -- From: "Patrice Lyons" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> To: "Robert Kahn" <

IAOC Responsibilities - updated

2005-01-26 Thread Robert Kahn
The following text largely tracks the message I posted to the IETF list on Tuesday afternoon, but it differs primarily in that the set of proposed additional IAOC Responsibilities (at the end of the message) have been tightened up as well as expanded based on numerous comments that I've received

IAOC Responsibilities

2005-01-25 Thread Robert Kahn
  It was recently pointed out that issues concerning confidentiality of information may not have been adequately addressed; patent submissions may also place additional constraints and restrictions on what individuals and organizations can do with intellectual property. Indeed, this is but one as

Re: Consensus? IPR rights and all that

2004-12-07 Thread Robert Kahn
The most helpful aspect of this exercise is that is is helping to define with the IETF what it wants to happen going forward. With good will and a certain amount of professionalism on all sides, I don't think it should be too hard to get from here to there. I agree that this is about the future

Perspectives on the IETF & Restructuring

2004-11-09 Thread Robert Kahn
I have not been involved in the public discussion of the IETF restructuring on this list so far, other than to make a plea at the most recent IETF plenary in San Diego to consider the various issues that are relevant to making any decisions about future restructuring. However, it would appear tha

Re: Cluster Addressing and CIDR

2003-01-22 Thread Robert Kahn
Vint, The internetting terminology was in existence as we wrote the tcp paper in 1973, but the internetting project got on the books formally in 1974, i think. I'd have to do a bit of digging to be sure. bob At 03:04 AM 1/15/2003 -0500, vinton g. cerf wrote: My first recollection of the docume