Re: ITU takes over?

2003-12-08 Thread vinton g. cerf
There have been fairly intense discussions in a series of meetings called PrepComs as in preparatory committees leading up to the World Summit on the Information Society (WSIS) taking place December 10-12 in Geneva. In the most recent meetings, a government only rule was invoked that excluded

Re: ITU takes over?

2003-12-08 Thread vinton g. cerf
Noel: 1. The Salt Lake Tribune: U.S. Net dominance questioned http://www.sltrib.com/2003/Dec/12082003/business/118003.asp 2. The Register: Internet showdown side-stepped in Geneva http://www.theregister.co.uk/content/6/34394.html 3. CNN Money: A potentially tangled Web?

Re: ITU takes over?

2003-12-08 Thread vinton g. cerf
at the moment it is not well constituted to develop policy. v At 01:01 PM 12/9/2003 +1200, Franck Martin wrote: Hmmm, What is wrong with ISOC? Cannot it be this body, we are looking for? Vint Cerf SVP Technology Strategy MCI 22001 Loudoun County Parkway, F2-4115 Ashburn, VA 20147 703 886 1690

Re: Re[3]: national security

2003-12-06 Thread vinton g. cerf
I don't know what jefsey means by IP zones Louis and I met in 1973 and his datagram ideas, sliding window ideas for flow control, influenced my thinking about TCP. Gerard LeLann, who worked in Louis Pouzin's group at IRIA came to Stanford in 1974 to work on the TCP and Internet. IEN 48 refers

Re: national security

2003-12-01 Thread vinton g. cerf
karl, ICANN has responsibility to do what it can to make sure the DNS and ICANN root system work. It does not have to disenfranchise the RIRs and the root servers to do this. vint At 12:02 AM 12/1/2003 -0800, Karl Auerbach wrote: Verisign will wave the flag of bias and ask ICANN to

Re: national security

2003-11-30 Thread vinton g. cerf
karl, we raised the question of anycast risk with SECSAC in response to your concerns and the conclusion was that the risks had not materialized in the operation of anycast in roots that had already deployed it. There are lots of ways in which routing can be wedged - until we get some form of

Re: national security

2003-11-29 Thread vinton g. cerf
At 05:49 PM 11/29/2003 +, Paul Robinson wrote: John C Klensin wrote: With regard to ICANN and its processes, I don't much like the way a good deal of that has turned out, even while I believe that things are gradually getting better. I lament the set of decisions that led to the US Govt

Re: national security

2003-11-29 Thread vinton g. cerf
At 03:39 PM 11/29/2003 -0800, Karl Auerbach wrote: On Sat, 29 Nov 2003, vinton g. cerf wrote: I strongly object to your characterization of ICANN as abandoning the operation of roots and IP address allocation. These matters have been the subject of discussion for some time. I can't seem

Re: FYI: BOF on Internationalized Email Addresses (IEA)

2003-10-30 Thread vinton g. cerf
Valdis, I think your example underscores the difference between localization of an interface to make use of local language/script and globalization that permits interworking among all parties, independent of their local language and script. the confusion between these two (familiar user

RE: conclusion for ALL YOUR WILDCARDS

2003-09-24 Thread vinton g. cerf
if you do that, I hope you will edit to manageable and understandable proportions... :-/ v At 10:50 PM 9/24/2003 +1000, Laird, James wrote: Maybe we should put together a summary of the discussion and send it to ICANN? Vint Cerf SVP Technology Strategy MCI 22001 Loudoun County Parkway, F2-4115

Re: Solving the right problems ...

2003-09-13 Thread vinton g. cerf
I am a strong proponent of trying to find a way to create a new set of end identifiers that would be insensitive to the changing of IP level addresses. It seems to me that we would find ourselves working pretty hard to tease apart the current strong binding of IP and TCP (pseudoheaders etc) but

Re: Proposal to define a simple architecture to differentiate legitimate bulk email from Spam (UBE)

2003-09-07 Thread vinton g. cerf
At 04:24 AM 9/8/2003 +0800, Shelby Moore wrote: At 11:51 AM 9/7/2003 +0800, you wrote: You can get mail no matter where you are with a POP account also. shelby, that's actually not true. If you have an enterprise email service that requires access to a VPN and the internet service you access it

Re: Solving the right problems ...

2003-09-03 Thread vinton g. cerf
At 08:41 AM 9/2/2003 -0700, Dave Crocker wrote: Vint, vgc If you look at the instant messaging systems, they map a private vgc identifier space (IM name or handle) into IP addresses and vgc apparently run background heartbeat to re-assign the mapping if the vgc identifier in the heartbeat arrives

Re: WG Review: Centralized Conferencing (xcon)

2003-08-21 Thread vinton g. cerf
keith, SIP may have been initially motivated by telephony style applications but it is a very general and extensible negotiation protocol - it was that aspect that grabbed my attention when I first heard about Schulzrinne's work on it several years ago. I think the point really is that SIP is

Re: WG Review: Centralized Conferencing (xcon)

2003-08-20 Thread vinton g. cerf
As a prospective supplier of SIP-based services, I am very interested in seeing SIP-based definitions for the support of a wide range of conferencing tools ranging from voice/video to IM and mixtures that might include a participant with only a phone and a fax machine. This is not to say that I

Re: non-complain mail system at alcatel.com

2003-06-23 Thread vinton g. cerf
I would be interested to know whether Alcatel really believes that DNS behaves in such a way that one MUST delegate at each dot - as far as I know, it is NOT required to do so. vint At 04:01 PM 6/22/2003 -0400, Michael Richardson wrote: -BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Alcatel.com does not

Re: The spam problem is political (Re: Engineering to deal with thesocial problem of spam)

2003-06-09 Thread vinton g. cerf
this is NOT an ICANN problem - ICANN has no jurisdiction at the email level. vint cerf chairman, ICANN At 12:27 AM 6/8/2003 +0200, Marc Schneiders wrote: Spam costs nothing. Spam comes from all corners of the world, where the Dutch police doesn't dare to go. And even if they would the Dutch

Re: Chest congestion

2003-03-19 Thread vinton g. cerf
Tony, bless you for your thoughtful concern - please keep me posted - I am scheduled to be in Singapore in early April. vint At 08:42 PM 3/18/2003 -0800, Tony Hain wrote: In the interest of full disclosure I want to let you all know that this evening I developed a deep chest cough. This

Re: Financial state of the IETF - to be presented Wednesday

2003-03-15 Thread vinton g. cerf
that would have to be a decision of PIR and its board - ISOC does not, at least as I understand it, have any direct access to the .org revenues. ISOC does select the PIR board but otherwise there is no financial connection. Vint At 12:08 PM 3/15/2003 -0800, Rick Wesson wrote: Harald, The

Re: Last Call: CR-LDP Extensions for ASON to Informational

2003-01-24 Thread vinton g. cerf
the reason for copyrighting the standards produced by IETF is precisely to simultaneously allow IETF to derive new standards documents from the older ones and to have the ability to prohibit others from doing so without specific authorization. Vint At 09:15 AM 1/24/2003 -0500, Scott Bradner

Re: Cluster Addressing and CIDR

2003-01-16 Thread vinton g. cerf
catanet was a term invented by Louis Pouzin, a French researcher responsible for the design and construction of the Cyclades system that included the Cigale pure datagram network. The term appeared in Internet Experiment Note #48 but as I recall was not used thereafter, when the term Internet

Re: Cluster Addressing and CIDR

2003-01-15 Thread vinton g. cerf
My first recollection of the documented use of the term Internet was in RFC 675 the specification of the Internet Transmission Control Protocol. ARPA called the project Internetting starting in 1973, I believe. Bob Kahn you know that point for sure. vint At 02:59 AM 1/15/2003 +0100, J-F C.

Re: Correction: Re: The 20th anniversary of the Internet

2002-12-21 Thread vinton g. cerf
yes, duh. v At 12:16 PM 12/21/2002 +, Peter KIRSTEIN wrote: In message [EMAIL PROTECTED] myou write: bob is correct; I left ARPA in Oct 1972 to join MCI. vint You mean 1982. Vint Cerf SVP Architecture Technology WorldCom 22001 Loudoun County Parkway, F2-4115 Ashburn, VA 20147 703 886

Re: Correction: Re: The 20th anniversary of the Internet

2002-12-20 Thread vinton g. cerf
bob is correct; I left ARPA in Oct 1972 to join MCI. vint At 07:49 PM 12/20/2002 +, Bob Braden wrote: In my recent message about the creation of the Internet by the conversion of the ARPAnet from NCP to TCP/IP, I incorrectly named Vint Cerf as the Responsible Parent at ARPA. Actually, the

Re: RFC publish rate

2002-12-18 Thread vinton g. cerf
do not confuse effort for progress vint cerf At 08:33 AM 12/19/2002 +0200, you wrote: Hi, Is it just me, or have RFC's been popping out lately like mushrooms in an autumn? Something seems to be working.. :-) Vint Cerf SVP Architecture Technology WorldCom 22001 Loudoun County Parkway,

Re: Root Server DDoS Attack: What The Media Did Not Tell You

2002-11-23 Thread vinton g. cerf
where are these statistics from - I cannot believe that more than a few percent of the net uses non-USG root. Vint At 09:10 AM 11/23/2002 -0500, Joe Baptista wrote: The root servers struck by the attack assist computers in translating Internet domain names, such as www.circleid.com, to numeric

Re: Root Server DDoS Attack: What The Media Did Not Tell You

2002-11-23 Thread vinton g. cerf
joe, this makes no sense to me - the cacheing mechanisms are essentially doing what you suggest. That's one of the reasons the system is resilient. But you need to invalidate the cache to deal with changes to the binding of domain name and IP address. Simply mirroring everything doesn't improve

Re: Root Server DDoS Attack: What The Media Did Not Tell You

2002-11-23 Thread vinton g. cerf
Louis Touton is Vice President and General Counsel of ICANN. ICANN has had a root server advisory committee from early days, working on root server placement to improve resilience; the security and stability advisory committee was created in the wake of 9/11 and has increased the priority of root

RE: APEX

2002-09-24 Thread vinton g. cerf
Louis Pouzin at INRIA coined the term datagram for use in his CIGALE/CYCLADES network around 1974. vint At 07:17 PM 9/23/2002 -0700, Dave Crocker wrote: At 06:46 PM 9/23/2002 -0700, Fred Baker wrote: A packet is a unit of data carried in a packet network, this just moves the question over

A note from France regarding the Terrorist's attack

2001-09-12 Thread vinton g. cerf
Jean-Noel is the senior advisor on Information Technology to the Prime Minister of France. vint Date: Wed, 12 Sep 2001 17:36:13 +0200 From: TRONC JEAN-NOEL [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: RE: TR: with you in this terrible moment. To: vint cerf [EMAIL PROTECTED] Importance: high Priority: Urgent

Re: Deployment vs the IPv6 community's ambivalence towards largeproviders

2000-08-22 Thread vinton g. cerf
I hope I will be forgiven for adding another message to this long thread. 1. we have to discuss the practical problems of deploying IPv6 and especially a bunch of corner cases or it won't work. 2. there are still a lot of "holes" in my opinion that need filling in any credible deployment

Re: more on IPv6 address space exhaustion

2000-08-11 Thread vinton g. cerf
the commission is not responsible for the assignment of IP address space is it??? vint At 02:53 PM 8/11/2000 -0700, Greg Skinner wrote: Brian E Carpenter [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: If a routeable prefix was given to every human, using a predicted world population of 11 billion, we would

RE: imode far superior to wap

2000-08-10 Thread vinton g. cerf
folks, our current plan is NOT to try to extend a single address space across the solar system. We plan to confine address spaces to planets, satellites, space vehicles and the backbone Internet - but each address space is independent. We plan to use something akin to the domain name system for

RE: Addresses and ports and taxes -- oh my!

2000-08-04 Thread vinton g. cerf
see www.ipnsig.org vint At 09:46 PM 8/3/2000 -0400, Philip J. Nesser II wrote: -BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA1 There is already a lot of work being done on the Interplanetary Internet problem. Vint Cerf has lead pioneering work with people at JPL on the problem. I don't

Re: Addresses and ports and taxes -- oh my!

2000-08-03 Thread vinton g. cerf
Dennis thanks for drawing attention to this question. One of the reasons for fees, of course, is that the Address Registries also have responsibility to support ICANN so they have some new costs in addition to their operating costs (or if you like, their operating costs include support for

Re: Complaint to Dept of Commerce on abuse of users by ICANN

2000-07-31 Thread vinton g. cerf
Greg, I am a strong proponent of developing and implementing accessibility guidelines. The ICANN election has simply overwhelmed the available resources - but I think the follow-on study absolutely should take into account accessibility concerns. vint At 08:02 AM 7/31/2000 -0700, Greg Skinner

Re: Complaint to Dept of Commerce on abuse of users by ICANN

2000-07-30 Thread vinton g. cerf
and I replied: Ronda, have you taken time to look into the numbers of people trying to register? do you know what the planning estimates were before registration campaigns were initiated by various organizations? The planning numbers for registration were on the order of 10,000 people. As of a

Internet vs internet

2000-07-07 Thread vinton g. cerf
Date: Fri, 07 Jul 2000 21:16:47 -0700 From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: Re: Defining "Internet" (or "internet") To: "vinton g. cerf" [EMAIL PROTECTED] X-Lotus-FromDomain: 3COM Original-recipient: rfc822;[EMAIL PROTECTED] Thanks for decip

Re: IPv6: Past mistakes repeated?

2000-05-10 Thread vinton g. cerf
ooops, sorry, I guess it was Paul that uncovered my retirement scheme. v At 10:10 AM 5/8/2000 +0100, Paul Robinson wrote: No! We don't want to fix the holes! We want to keep a record of them without telling the admins, and when they misbehave, not only can we pop their kneecaps, set fire to

RE: IPv6: Past mistakes repeated?

2000-05-10 Thread vinton g. cerf
At 10:39 AM 5/8/2000 -0700, Jim Stephenson-Dunn wrote: No! We don't want to fix the holes! We want to keep a record of them without telling the admins, and when they misbehave, not only can we pop their kneecaps, set fire to their house, release information to their families they wouldn't want to

Re: draft-ietf-nat-protocol-complications-02.txt

2000-04-30 Thread vinton g. cerf
that's right - they use iMODE on the DOCOMO mobiles. iMODE and WAP seem to have that in common: a non-IP radio link protocol and an application gateway. Of course, this limits the applications to those that can be "translated" in the gateway, while an end to end system (such as the Ricochet from

RE: IPv6: Past mistakes repeated?

2000-04-25 Thread vinton g. cerf
For those of you who don't know, and Jim is too modest to tell you, he was a member of the Stanford team that designed and implemented the first TCP protocol versions. Later he went on to build the first versions for the portable Digital LSI-11s used in the Packet Radio network. Vint

Re: draft-ietf-nat-protocol-complications-02.txt

2000-04-22 Thread vinton g. cerf
big smile - vBNS+ is running IPv6 on a commercial basis. I'd be more than interested in your opinion of a sensible (acceptable) policy on the minimum size of IPv6 space one might expect to allocate to customers. Vint At 09:08 PM 4/22/2000 -0500, Richard Shockey wrote: And yes I have a credit