Ted, Sam,
I also agree with your points, and yes, even personnel decisions
by AD can be appealed. The appeals process is not intended to
merely inspect whether formal right to perform an action existed;
such appeals would be very easily decided. In most cases, an
appeal involves an action which
Ted, speaking as an individual.
I completely agree that personnel decisions of ADs should be able to
be appealed. I actually considered proposing text modifications to
make it clear that there might be circumstances where it would be
appropriate for the IESG to resolve the conflict.
I and I
Ted:
With great respect, I must disagree. The appeal says: It is the
position of the appellants that this removal violates the IETF
process by which working groups are governed. This say to me that
the appellants believe that Cullen Jennings violated IETF process by
replacing the GEOPRIV
At 1:16 PM -0400 9/21/07, Russ Housley wrote:
Ted:
With great respect, I must disagree. The appeal says: It is the position of
the appellants that this removal violates the IETF process by which working
groups are governed. This say to me that the appellants believe that Cullen
Jennings
