Fwd: Re: [dnsext] Deprecating SPF

2013-08-26 Thread Mark Andrews
--- Forwarded Message To: Michael Richardson From: Mark Andrews References: <20130819222037.ga55...@mx1.yitter.info> <20130822184610.2640.qm...@joyce.lan> <20130822212337.b37a838cb...@drugs.dv.isc.org> <5559.1377478...@sandelman.ca> Subject: Re: [dnsext] Dep

Re: [dnsext] Deprecating SPF

2013-08-22 Thread Mark Andrews
Part of the question is whether the IETF is going to work with ICANN, IANA and the ccTLD to audit delegations for servers that are not RFC 103[45] compliant and suspend delegations where the servers are not compliant. * no responding to queries based on query type * not having a N

Re: [dnsext] Deprecating SPF

2013-08-20 Thread Patrik Fältström
On 20 aug 2013, at 21:30, S Moonesamy wrote: > First of all, I apologize for copying the message to ietf@. No apology needed. > I don't know whether to process your comments or the other comments posted on > dnsext@ as part of the Last Call or not. It is unclear to me as to whether I > shou

Re: [dnsext] Deprecating SPF

2013-08-20 Thread S Moonesamy
Hi Patrik, At 11:45 20-08-2013, Patrik Fältström wrote: The reason why I did not post there at first was that a) I did not feel I had followed the rules laid out for discussions [read all messages in the mailing list archives] and b) the discussion on the dnsext list was more general on overlo

Re: [dnsext] Deprecating SPF

2013-08-20 Thread Patrik Fältström
On 20 aug 2013, at 20:36, S Moonesamy wrote: > It would be better to have the discussion on the ietf@ mailing list as that's > the venue which the IESG identified for last Call comments. Understood, and thanks. The reason why I did not post there at first was that a) I did not feel I had foll

Re: [dnsext] Deprecating SPF

2013-08-20 Thread S Moonesamy
Hi Patrik, I am copying the message to ieft@ as there is an ongoing Last Call. At 08:28 20-08-2013, Patrik Fältström wrote: The consensus related to how to fix RFC 4408 will be very rough. That is clear. And I feel sorry for responsible AD and IESG to be forced to make a decision that such a