Re: How to protect DKIM signatures: Moving ADSP to Historic, supporting DMARC instead

2013-10-03 Thread Hector Santos
On 10/3/2013 6:25 PM, Douglas Otis wrote: On Oct 3, 2013, at 1:37 PM, Barry Leiba wrote: To both Doug and Hector, and others who want to drift in this direction: As I've said before, the question of moving ADSP to Historic is one we're taking on its own, and is not connected to anything we d

Re: How to protect DKIM signatures: Moving ADSP to Historic, supporting DMARC instead

2013-10-03 Thread Douglas Otis
On Oct 3, 2013, at 1:37 PM, Barry Leiba wrote: > To both Doug and Hector, and others who want to drift in this direction: > > As I've said before, the question of moving ADSP to Historic is one > we're taking on its own, and is not connected to anything we do or > don't do with DMARC. Bringing

Re: How to protect DKIM signatures: Moving ADSP to Historic, supporting DMARC instead

2013-10-03 Thread Hector Santos
Please accept my apology as I do not mean to be disrespectful. I find it impossible to separate all design considerations that are involved in this decision you are requesting us to consider regarding a near 7-8 years DKIM + POLICY investment. DKIM originated with POLICY support built-in and i

Re: How to protect DKIM signatures: Moving ADSP to Historic, supporting DMARC instead

2013-10-03 Thread Barry Leiba
To both Doug and Hector, and others who want to drift in this direction: As I've said before, the question of moving ADSP to Historic is one we're taking on its own, and is not connected to anything we do or don't do with DMARC. Bringing DMARC into the discussion is a distraction, and, worse, mak

How to protect DKIM signatures: Moving ADSP to Historic, supporting DMARC instead

2013-10-03 Thread Hector Santos
On 10/3/2013 1:51 PM, Douglas Otis wrote: Dear Hector, Indeed, more should be said about underlying reasons. The reason for abandoning ADSP is for the same reason few providers reject messages not authorized by SPF records ending in "-all" (FAIL). Mailing-List software existed long before e