Questions on my role as the 2007-8 nomcom chair and the various discussions on the IETF list

2007-06-13 Thread Lakshminath Dondeti
Folks, One person has voiced concerns on my "taking a strong public position" in the "Should I* opinions be afforded a special status?" thread while serving as the chair of the 2007-8 nomcom. Perhaps there are others with similar concerns. The role of the nomcom chair is clearly described i

Re: Questions on my role as the 2007-8 nomcom chair and the various discussions on the IETF list

2007-06-13 Thread Eliot Lear
I realize we're well into meta-discussions here, but quite frankly I find it refreshing that the NOMCOM chair is questioning the qualities that an IESG should have. Not only do I think it appropriate, but I hope that the selectees feel comfortable asking questions about these sorts of things,

Re: Questions on my role as the 2007-8 nomcom chair and the various discussions on the IETF list

2007-06-14 Thread Stephen Kent
At 12:29 AM -0700 6/13/07, Lakshminath Dondeti wrote: Folks, One person has voiced concerns on my "taking a strong public position" in the "Should I* opinions be afforded a special status?" thread while serving as the chair of the 2007-8 nomcom. Perhaps there are others with similar concerns