RE: IETF IP Contribution Policy

2007-01-27 Thread Yaakov Stein
Larry Rosen, It is indicative of your letter's content that the introduction informs us that the IETF is the SDO responsible for Ethernet and WiFi (well, they both start with IE don't they?). Getting down to the letter itself. IETF, the most democratic and open of standards organizations,

RE: IETF IP Contribution Policy

2007-01-24 Thread Hallam-Baker, Phillip
Well you start by mistaking the IETF for a democratic body. It isn't. There are no members and no elections. I don't think that you are raising issues that the IETF participants are not aware of. All things being equal practically every participant would prefer RAND+Zero cost licensing terms on