Re: mailing list memberships reminder - passwords in the clear

2012-11-28 Thread Rich Kulawiec
First, an enthusiastic +1 to Steve's comments re security being compatible with risk. Second, Mailman is -- at this point -- easily the best available option for mailing list management. That is not to say it's perfect, of course it's not -- but in terms of capability, support, development,

Re: [IETF] Re: mailing list memberships reminder - passwords in the clear

2012-11-03 Thread Warren Kumari
On Nov 2, 2012, at 3:56 PM, John R Levine jo...@taugh.com wrote: Why does the mailing list memberships reminder send passwords in the clear? Because that's what Mailman does. Send code. And that's acceptable to the IETF? You're kidding me, right? I can't speak for the IETF, but I do

Re: mailing list memberships reminder - passwords in the clear

2012-11-03 Thread Paul Aitken
John, Why does the mailing list memberships reminder send passwords in the clear? Because that's what Mailman does. Send code. And that's acceptable to the IETF? You're kidding me, right? P.

Re: mailing list memberships reminder - passwords in the clear

2012-11-03 Thread Paul Aitken
are never sent in the clear. I find it hard to understand that this is acceptable to the IETF. Thanks, P. On 1 Nov 2012, at 20:20, Paul Aitken pait...@cisco.com wrote: Why does the mailing list memberships reminder send passwords in the clear? Because mailman is brain-dead stupid. See: http

Re: mailing list memberships reminder - passwords in the clear

2012-11-03 Thread Paul Aitken
John, I can't speak for the IETF, but I do note that the same password notices have been going out on the first of every month for years. You just noticed iit now? No, I've been getting the passwords for years. However I just finished a crypto class and really wondered what the history is

Re: mailing list memberships reminder - passwords in the clear

2012-11-03 Thread Steven Bellovin
On Nov 2, 2012, at 3:39 PM, Paul Aitken pait...@cisco.com wrote: John, Why does the mailing list memberships reminder send passwords in the clear? Because that's what Mailman does. Send code. And that's acceptable to the IETF? You're kidding me, right? Because the security

Re: mailing list memberships reminder - passwords in the clear

2012-11-03 Thread Sabahattin Gucukoglu
On 2 Nov 2012, at 21:51, John Levine jo...@taugh.com wrote: Only majordomo2, which has been unmaintained for a while now (and it's author calls it Dead holds much of a chance, but I doubt it ?would work for the IETF in its current condition. Actually, MJ2 works great, I've been using it in

mailing list memberships reminder - passwords in the clear

2012-11-02 Thread Paul Aitken
Why does the mailing list memberships reminder send passwords in the clear? For everything else I'm subscribed to, if I forget my details, one click sends a one-time password-reset link. Passwords are never mailed out, and never shown. Thanks, P.

Re: mailing list memberships reminder - passwords in the clear

2012-11-02 Thread John Levine
In article 5092d99f.3070...@cisco.com you write: Why does the mailing list memberships reminder send passwords in the clear? Because that's what Mailman does. Send code. -- Regards, John Levine, jo...@iecc.com, Primary Perpetrator of The Internet for Dummies, Please consider the environment

Re: mailing list memberships reminder - passwords in the clear

2012-11-02 Thread Sabahattin Gucukoglu
On 1 Nov 2012, at 20:20, Paul Aitken pait...@cisco.com wrote: Why does the mailing list memberships reminder send passwords in the clear? Because mailman is brain-dead stupid. See: http://www.jwz.org/doc/mailman.html Sadly, and despite my best efforts to find alternative mailing list software

Re: mailing list memberships reminder - passwords in the clear

2012-11-02 Thread Mike Brescia
privacy, claims passwords will not be /en clair/) On Nov 2, 2012, at 11:24 AM, John Levine wrote: In article 5092d99f.3070...@cisco.com you write: Why does the mailing list memberships reminder send passwords in the clear? Because that's what Mailman does. Send code. -- Regards, John

Re: mailing list memberships reminder - passwords in the clear

2012-11-02 Thread John R Levine
Why does the mailing list memberships reminder send passwords in the clear? Because that's what Mailman does. Send code. And that's acceptable to the IETF? You're kidding me, right? I can't speak for the IETF, but I do note that the same password notices have been going out on the first

Re: mailing list memberships reminder - passwords in the clear

2012-11-02 Thread John Levine
Only majordomo2, which has been unmaintained for a while now (and it's author calls it Dead holds much of a chance, but I doubt it ?would work for the IETF in its current condition. Actually, MJ2 works great, I've been using it in production for years, but I agree that we'd need to locate a perl