Re: [ietf-dkim] Issue 1530 - replace use of term suspicious

2007-12-16 Thread Steve Atkins
On Dec 16, 2007, at 9:10 AM, Dave Crocker wrote: Jon Callas wrote: Dave Crocker wrote: With the use of language like suspicious, SSP is making value judgement on messages that do not satisfy SSP's criteria, even though those message well might be entirely legitimate. ... How about

Re: [ietf-dkim] Issue 1530 - replace use of term suspicious

2007-12-16 Thread Wietse Venema
Steve Atkins: On Dec 16, 2007, at 9:10 AM, Dave Crocker wrote: Jon Callas wrote: Dave Crocker wrote: With the use of language like suspicious, SSP is making value judgement on messages that do not satisfy SSP's criteria, even though those message well might be entirely

Re: [ietf-dkim] Issue 1530 - replace use of term suspicious

2007-12-16 Thread Hector Santos
Dave Crocker wrote: Jon Callas wrote: Dave Crocker wrote: With the use of language like suspicious, SSP is making value judgement on messages that do not satisfy SSP's criteria, even though those message well might be entirely legitimate. ... How about something like SSP Exception?

Re: [ietf-dkim] Issue 1530 - replace use of term suspicious

2007-12-16 Thread Michael Thomas
Dave Crocker wrote: Jon Callas wrote: Dave Crocker wrote: With the use of language like suspicious, SSP is making value judgement on messages that do not satisfy SSP's criteria, even though those message well might be entirely legitimate. ... How about something like SSP Exception?

RE: [ietf-dkim] Issue 1530 - replace use of term suspicious

2007-12-16 Thread Bill.Oxley
Please mark issue closed as exception denotes just that -Original Message- From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] on behalf of Dave Crocker Sent: Sun 12/16/2007 12:10 PM To: DKIM WG Subject: [ietf-dkim] Issue 1530 - replace use of term suspicious Jon Callas wrote: Dave Crocker wrote: With the use

RE: [ietf-dkim] Issue 1530 - exception

2007-12-16 Thread Bill.Oxley
The word denotes failure of a rule in rule based systems you have a decision tree with EITHER pattern match OR exception to pattern match SSP at a glance appears to be a rule based policy engine. Exception as opposed to Suspicious emphasizes that. Receivers can base their policy on SSP in a

Re: [ietf-dkim] Issue 1530 - exception

2007-12-16 Thread Dave Crocker
Bill, [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: The word denotes failure of a rule in rule based systems you have a decision tree with EITHER pattern match OR exception to pattern match SSP at a glance appears to be a rule based policy engine. Exception as opposed to Suspicious emphasizes that. Receivers can

Re: [ietf-dkim] Issue 1530 - replace use of term suspicious

2007-12-16 Thread Jim Fenton
Michael Thomas wrote: Dave Crocker wrote: Jon Callas wrote: Dave Crocker wrote: With the use of language like suspicious, SSP is making value judgement on messages that do not satisfy SSP's criteria, even though those message well might be entirely legitimate. ... How about something

Re: [ietf-dkim] Issue 1530 - replace use of term suspicious

2007-12-16 Thread Dave Crocker
Michael Thomas wrote: How about something like SSP Exception? Metaphorically, it works well with the programming use of the word exception. In the hope of trying to close some of the easy Issues, would folks comment on this specific proposal, or otherwise post comments seeking closure of