Re: [ietf-dkim] Domain Existence Check ssp-03 vs levine-adsp-00

2008-05-30 Thread Jeff Macdonald
On Fri, 2008-05-30 at 01:28 -0400, Tony Hansen wrote: > My conclusions from reading ssp-03 and the proposed rewording of section > 4.3 found in levine-adsp-00 and otis-adsp-02 is that: > > * ssp-03 and levine-adsp-00 require that you check that the domain > exists. Yes, except the outcome

Re: [ietf-dkim] Domain Existence Check ssp-03 vs levine-adsp-00

2008-05-30 Thread John Levine
>If the result of this query is an "NXDOMAIN" error, the algorithm MUST >terminate with an appropriate error. > >>From this text, I don't really understand what the appropriate error is. >I suspect it really should say "appropriate result". It's intended to say that you know the address is no good