Re: [Imports] Import guidelines - official or not? was: [Talk-us] parcel data in OSM

2013-01-01 Thread Frederik Ramm
Hi, On 01.01.2013 18:58, Jeff Meyer wrote: Would you mind if I excerpted some of your email for use on the wiki? No, that's fine, as long as you don't write that what I said was the official policy ;) Bye Frederik -- Frederik Ramm ## eMail frede...@remote.org ## N49°00'09" E008°23'33"

Re: [Imports] Import guidelines - official or not? was: [Talk-us] parcel data in OSM

2013-01-01 Thread Jeff Meyer
On Tue, Jan 1, 2013 at 5:49 AM, Frederik Ramm wrote: > I hope this explanation was helpful. I believe it was very helpful! Would you mind if I excerpted some of your email for use on the wiki? My goal is to communicate the spirit of what you've said so that newcomers, who haven't been on the l

Re: [Imports] Import guidelines - official or not? was: [Talk-us] parcel data in OSM

2013-01-01 Thread Christian Quest
2013/1/1 Frederik Ramm : > Not having hard-and-fast official rules also means there's no rule lawyering > - no way for someone to find a loophole and claim immunity because they > follwed the letter and not the spirit of a rule. official rules are not incompatible with "spirit of rule" approach (w

Re: [Imports] Example of defective import

2013-01-01 Thread Greg Troxel
Frederik Ramm writes: > It seems that JOSM was used for uploading this, and today's JOSM > validator would have spotted the problem (it reports 9 duplicated > ways, 122 ways with same position, 287 self-intersecting ways and many > more), but it is possible that back in 2011 when this was made,

Re: [Imports] Import guidelines - official or not? was: [Talk-us] parcel data in OSM

2013-01-01 Thread Greg Troxel
Frederik Ramm writes: > I hope this explanation was helpful. Thanks for posting that explanation. I found it to be very level-headed and reasonable, and a good explanation of DWG's approach of treading lightly with respect to detailed rules. After having been on talk-us@ for almost 4 years an

Re: [Imports] Import guidelines - official or not? was: [Talk-us] parcel data in OSM

2013-01-01 Thread Frederik Ramm
Hi, Can you provide a link to the guidelines the DWG uses? ... Please note that this guidelines on this page (http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Import/Guidelines) are the ones cited by DWG members when they request sysadmins to place blocks on accounts that are importing I'm kind of unsur

[Imports] Example of defective import

2013-01-01 Thread Frederik Ramm
Hi, the German forum came up with a nice example of what can happen if import scripts don't work as expected: http://www.openstreetmap.org/browse/node/1225280729 - a node that is part of over 200 ways ;) Trying to show these ways on the API "browse" page results in an error 500, probably